*
banner

CD review: Holst at 150 — A Brass Celebration

Martyn Brabbins, Ian Porthouse and Tredegar Band bring a finely executed and thoughtfully conceived celebration of the musical fortunes of the Holst family to life.


Tredegar Town Band 
Conductors: Ian Porthouse, Martyn Brabbins
Doyen Recordings: DOY CD435

With Tredegar having celebrated the 150th birthday of Vaughan Williams just two years ago, their focus now embraces that of his contemporary, Gustav Holst.

The pair certainly enjoyed, and were inspired by each other’s company and music, although the more intriguing question surrounds the creative direction that Holst’s ever searching mind might have taken had he lived the more robust life of his friend (Holst died in 1934 aged 59, Vaughan Williams passing aged 85 in 1958).  

Sadly, we shall never know, but one of the fascinating elements of this recording is the inclusion of music by his daughter Imogen (1907-84).  Her multiplicity of talents, for long hidden in the shadow of her father, were only to be recognised fully long after his death.

Advocates

Both were enthusiastic brass band advocates; Gustav giving his early blessing to arrangements of his two ‘Suites’  in Eb and F for wind band. Those of Sidney Herbert have remained firmly in the repertoire, but now Phillip Littlemore has breathed new life into them.

The results are absorbing –  tonally brighter in restoration to their original keys, the revived subtlety of colour and texture, allied with the re-introduction of cut bars bringing a new sense of vitality.

The results are absorbing – the brace tonally brighter in restoration to their original keys, the revived subtlety of colour and texture, allied with the re-introduction of cut bars bringing a new sense of vitality.

‘A Fugal Overture’  is less well known outside orchestral circles, but Alastair Wheeler’s new transcription of a brief but exhilarating work is captured in a performance that brims with energised detail and rhythmic vivacity.

Ingenuity

The ballet music from ‘The Perfect Fool’  already exists in an arrangement by Peter Parkes. Phillip Littlemore once again though draws new depth to the detail with the ingenuity of his scoring. Equally telling is the feeling of faithfulness to the original instilled by the performance. 

Imogen Holst’s ‘The Unfortunate Traveller’  has a fascinating back story - one that saw her forced by academic circumstance to ‘arrange’ it for string orchestra as she could not submit an examination piece for brass band.

Now, thanks to a refined restoration by Paul Hindmarsh it fully reveals her quirkily distilled responses to her love of English folk and dance music. 

Now, thanks to a refined restoration by Paul Hindmarsh it fully reveals her quirkily distilled responses to her love of English folk and dance music. 

‘The Glory of the West’  displays unorthodoxy too - written by Imogen in response to a commission from Redbridge Youth Brass Band in 1969. It must have sounded oddly unfashionable at the time, yet its light scoring retains a playful sense of timeless wit. 

Of which, in ‘Mr Shilkret’s Maggot’,   Paul Hindmarsh unearths a whimsical gem. Originally written for American Nathaniel Shilkret’s jazz radio orchestra, it wears its English dryness as a badge of honour, played with waspish panache.

Eloquent

Martyn Brabbins’ eloquent exploration of ‘A Moorside Suite’  crowns an outstanding release with interpretive insight that draws playing that exudes rich, warmly hued character.

Martyn Brabbins’ eloquent exploration of ‘A Moorside Suite’  crowns an outstanding release with interpretive insight that draws playing that exudes rich, warmly hued character.

The lightness of the ‘Scherzo’  is a sophisticated delight, joyful in its uninhibited flow. It contrasts the poignant sense of era in the central ‘Nocturne’  evoking in its descending thirds and sixths a bucolic land that the composer knew was fast disappearing around him.

The ‘March’, with its military precision, has a sense of expectancy - vigorous yet agile, that brings to a close a finely executed and thoughtfully conceived tribute (made in association with the Holst Society) to both father and daughter. 

Christopher Thomas


To purchase: 

CD: https://www.worldofbrass.com/102175

Download: https://www.worldofbrass.com/102175-download

Wobplay: http://www.wobplay.com

Play list:

1. First Suite in Eb (Op.28 No. 1) (Gustav Holst arr. Philip Littlemore)
i. Chaconne
ii. Intermezzo
iii. March

4. Second Suite in F (Op.28 No. 2 (Gustav Holst arr. Philip Littlemore)
i. March
ii. Song without worlds: “I’ll love my love”
iii. Song of the Blacksmith
iv. Fantasia on the “Dargason”

8. A Fugal Overture (Op.40 No. 1) (Gustav Holst arr. Alastair Wheeler)
9. Ballet Music from The Perfect Fool (Gustav Holst arr. Philip Littlemore)

10. The Unfortunate Traveller (Imogen Holst edit. Paul Hindmarsh)
i. Introduction
ii. Scherzo
iii. Interlude
iv. March

14. The Glory of the West (Imogen Holst)
15. Mr Shilktet’s Maggot (Gustav Holst arr. Paul Hindmarsh)

16. A Moorside Suite (Gustav Holst)
i. Scherzo
ii. Nocturne
iii. March

Support us for less than a cup of coffee...

4BR wants to ensure that the brass band movement remains vibrant and relevant. We also want to be able to question, challenge and critically examine those who run and play in it, producing high quality journalism that informs as well as entertains our readers.

So if like us you value a strong, independent perspective on the brass band world - then why not consider becoming a supporter and help make our future and that of a burgeoning brass band movement more secure.

So one less cappuccino then?

Support us    



Regent Hall Concerts - Royal College of Music Sackbut Ensemble

Friday 21 February • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - The Band of the Welsh Guards

Friday 21 February • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Newstead Brass - Midlands Championships Preview Evening

Sunday 23 February • Summit Centre . Kirkby in Ashfield . Nottinghamshire NG17 7LL


Contest: North West Regional Championships

Sunday 23 February • Winter Gardens Complex, Church Street, Blackpool FY1 1HU


Regent Hall Concerts - Royal Greenwich Brass Band

Friday 28 February • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Reading Spring Gardens Brass Band

February 20 • Reading Band still needs LOWER BRASS for the 4th section contest at Stevenage on Saturday 15th March! Rehearsals in Woodley (RG5) on Thursday evenings.


Boarshurst Silver Band

February 17 • Boarshurst Silver Band, NW Championship Section, requires a BBb player, flugel, and front row cornet player. Under MD Jamie Prophet, the band have an ambitious and varied calendar for 2025, including NW Area, Spring Festival and Whit Friday.


Mid Rhondda Band

February 14 • Mid Rhondda Band are looking for the following players : Front Row Cornet, Solo Trombone, Eb Bass, Kit and Tuned Percussionists. The band will be competing in the 3rd Section at the Welsh Area. Contest & concert engagements in the diary for 2025


Stephen Tighe

ARCM, LDBBA, (Dip)PFS.
Adjudicator / Music Director / Arranger


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd