Steve Mead has unveiled the programme for his forthcoming seminar at the RNCM in Manchester on criteria based adjudication on 28th January.
1.30pm – 5.00pm: Studio Theatre
1.30pm – 1.40pm: Introductions and the background to the debate.
The need for transparency: Is there anything wrong with the current system?
1.40pm – 2.15pm: Outline of the 2010 experiment
Feedback and analysis
1.55pm – 2.15pm: A look at the judging experiment criteria.
What is good and what needs changing?
2.15 – 2.40pm: Possible alternative criteria systems
Is this ‘tick box’ or analytical adjudication? Alternative marking systems?
2.40pm – 3.05pm: Open or closed adjudication?
The whole performance experience or just aural comparison? Is it just about trust?
3.20pm – 4.00pm: A live experiment.
Three brass band quartets performing.
4.00pm – 4.55pm: Open debate:
Should criteria based adjudication be given a chance in UK brass band competitions, and if so should it be open or closed adjudication.
Chairman: Dr Martin Harlow BA(Dunelm), MPhil(Sheffield), PhD(Sheffield), Dip.NCOS, ARCM . Dean of Academic Studies – RNCM
Can we move towards a consensus? What are the mechanisms for change?
4.55pm – 5.00pm: Conclusions
For more information go to: http://www.euphonium.net/home.php?newsID=238
