*
banner

Peripatetic battle continues in Scotland

Accusations of betrayal ramp up rhetoric in hope that Scottish Government will intervene to protect music services.

Music
  The Scottish Government is now been asked to intervene

The ongoing battle to secure free peripatetic music service provision in all of Scotland's schools continues to make headlines.

It gained further traction this week with the publication of a hard hitting article published in 'Holyrood Magazine', the influential magazine for policy makers, ministers, MSPs and political workers in Scotland.

Money making

Written by Margaret Taylor it accuses East Ayrshire Council of "betrayal"in its definition of what they think school education in respect to music service provision is after it transferred its instrumental music service to what the writer said was "a money making leisure trust".

One parent has now taken out a Section 70 complaint with Scottish ministers to back their assertion that the Scottish Government's position is clear in that music provision is a key part of education provision and that East Ayrshire is failing in its legal obligations.

Betrayal

The parent is quoted as saying that the decision in "taking the music service away from the education system is undermining it."

They added: "It's as if the council sees music tuition as an extra-curricular activity when it's always been a part of, and is important to, children learning.

This feels like a betrayal — it feels like the council is going back on the government's decision on music lessons. It feels like instrumental tuition gets pushed to the side and when the council is looking at cuts it gets targeted. They don't seem to realise how important it is."

Response

The article noted a response given Council Leader Douglas Reid who said that the authority was moving into an "incredibly challenging financial period".

He added that the new trust would be able to generate funds via "food and beverage opportunities, alongside events, skills and training, and residential holidays.

East Ayrshire Leisure is in a better position to sustain, enhance and grow the services that are included within this review, as they have a greater ability to develop a more agile, entrepreneurial culture and have access to a wider range of funding sources."

This feels like a betrayal — it feels like the council is going back on the government's decision on music lessonsparent

Political outcome?

The need for a definitive political outcome through the intervention of the Scottish Government has the support of long time campaigner Ralph Ruddiough.

He was is quoted as saying: "What we need is a political solution, because within five years of them saying it was fixed it is all falling apart.

I'd like to think the decision East Ayrshire Council has made will spur Scottish Ministers into again finding a solution."

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


National Finals

Nationals line-ups complete

March 24 • The bands that have been invited to compete at London and Cheltenham has now been completed.


Purcell School

Cobb and Vollam team up for free Purcell recital

March 22 • Philip Cobb and Helen Vollam will be joined by pianist Liz Burley for a free recital evening at The Purcell School — and all are welcome.


bRIGHOUSE

Rittchie fits Brighouse euph requirements to a tee

March 22 • There will be an all Scottish euphonium section at Brighouse & Rastrick as the West Riding band welcomes Angus Rittchie.


Tom Hutchinson

Book your Granada place with Tom in the hills

March 22 • There is still time to book a very special week away with Tom Hutchinson...


Contest: North of England Regional Championships

Sunday 23 March • 1 Millennium Place, Durham DH1 1WA


The Hepworth Band - Glossop Band Club

Sunday 23 March • Glossop Band Club, Derby Street, Glossop SK13 8LP


Longridge Band - Longridge Youth Band Concert

Sunday 23 March • St. Lawrence's Church, Chapel Hill, Longridge PR3 2YD


Dobcross Silver Band - Ashton Band

Sunday 23 March • c/o Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross Saddleworth OL3 5AD


Regent Hall Concerts - The Band of the Grenadier Guards

Friday 28 March • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Ocean Brass

March 23 • Ocean Brass (2nd section) are seeking a new Musical Director, due to a change in personal circumstances of our previous MD. We rehearse on Thursdays 8-10pm, at Banister Park Bowls Club, Stoneham Lane, Southampton SO50 9HT.


Chinnor Silver

March 22 • Our COMMUNITY BAND meets on a Monday and would welcome players of all abilities to join us for a relaxed rehearsal with coffee and cake.Its just a chance for an extra blow that doesn't affect you affiliation to your existing bands.


Hebden Bridge Brass Band

March 21 • Hebden Bridge Band require the following to complete our line for 2025.. PRINCIPAL CORNET, BACKROW CORNET, TENOR TROMBONE & PERCUSSION. We have an exciting line up planned, including Buxton contest, Whit Friday and local concert series, plus a good local!


Stuart Black

BA (Hons) Music
Conductor, Teacher, Flugel soloist


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd