Butlin's solo mistake rectified as Smith takes award

Jamie Smith of Flowers Band will be presented with the Geoff Dove Soloist Award from the entertainment element of the Butlin's Championship Section contest after result mistake is rectified.

  Jamie Smith was the correct winner of the Geoff Dove Mineworkers Soloists Challenge Shield

A misunderstanding over the identity of the correct winner of the Geoff Dove Mineworkers Soloist Challenge Shield in the Championship Section Entertainment element at the Butlins Open Brass Band Festival has been rectified by the contest organisers.

Smith not Wyatt

At the results ceremony on Sunday evening, Desford Colliery principal cornet Gary Wyatt was somewhat surprisingly announced as the winner of the award, even though he had not been a featured solo player in the band's programme.

However it has since transpired the correct winner should have been Jamie Smith of Flowers Band who gave an outstanding solo performance of 'St Paul's from Fleet Street' during their winning programme.

4BR understands that the winning choice of the judges referred to the band drawn number 2 in the entertainment discipline — although this was mistakenly understood by officials as the band that had come second.


Speaking to 4BR Flowers MD said: "I received a telephone call from Stan Lippeatt this morning to explain the situation. He offered the apologies of the contest organisers for their mistake and stated that arrangement will be made to get the trophy to Jamie as soon as possible.

We are grateful to Stan for taking the time to explain the unfortunate mistake to us in person. We know that these things can happen at brass band contests, but it is good that they are rectified through direct contact and an apology."

He added: "We'll now make sure Jamie receives the award and prize money with a picture to record him winning a rather unique solo prize."

Deserved winner

Meanwhile, Gary Wyatt of Desford also offered his congratulations to Jamie. "I have to admit I was more than a little surprised myself on hearing that I won the award,"he said.

"I've had quite a bit of good humoured ribbing about it because it did seem strange that the only time I took a bow was at the end of the performance with the rest of the band!

I was contacted today by Mick Veasey from the contest organisers who explained what happened. That was appreciated."

He added: "This was a genuine mistake, but an unfortunate one — and especially for Jamie. It would have been appropriate for Jamie to have received the award on the stage on Sunday night and accept the applause for his wonderful playing. He fully deserved to win it."

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    

Paul Cosh

Tuesday interview with Paul Cosh

January 18 • We speak to the highly respected player, conductor, teacher and lecturer about his new teaching publication — 'Brass Essentials — An Arban Collection'.


Empty seats filled at Littleport

January 18 • Littleport Brass has filled their empty seats ahead of their Area challnge in a few weeks time.

New signings

New additions at Ratby Mid Band

January 18 • New faces young and old join the set-up at Ratby Mid Band in time for their assault on the Midlands Area title.


75 years of brass and coal

January 18 • The national newspaper will hopefully remember the link between brass bands and the National Coal Board this weekend thanks to photographer Lorne Campbell.

Contest: 168th British Open

Sunday 23 January • Symphony Hall, Broad Street, Birmingham. B1 2EA

Glossop Old Band - Cadishead Public Band

Sunday 23 January • Glossop Band Club, Derby Street, Glossop. SK13 8LP

Black Dyke Band - RNCM Brass Band Festival

Saturday 29 January • Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9RD

Regent Hall Concerts - The International Staff Band of the Salvation Army

Saturday 29 January • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London WC1 2 DJ

Black Dyke Band - Gladstone Theatre

Sunday 30 January • Greendale Road, Birkenhead, Wirral CH62 4XB

The Cobham Band

January 17 • The Cobham Band is fully up and running again and requires a EUPHONIUM or BARITONE player. We have some great concerts planned including bandstand dates for the new season under our new conductor, Jim Lynch.. .

Shrewsbury Brass Band

January 15 • Are you looking for a change of scene or want to get back into banding with an ambitious and hardworking band? We have a vacancy for an experienced front row cornet player, BBb Bass player, and 2 percussionists.

Reading Spring Gardens Brass Band

January 15 • A vacancy exists for a capable and committed **EEb BASS PLAYER ** to join the band as it establishes itself in the third section.

Duncan A. Beckley

Conductor, adjudicator, band trainer and teacher


 © 2022 4barsrest.com Ltd