*
banner

Report & Results: 2016 Senior Trophy

Filton Concert Brass navigates the James Cook waters to claim the Senior Trophy in fine style.

Filton Concert Brass
 

The continued rise to top section contesting prominence of Filton Concert Brass was aided by a splendid Senior Trophy success in Blackpool on the weekend.

Directed by Tom Davoren, the band based just outside Bristol delivered an outstanding performance of Gilbert Vinter's 'James Cook Circumnavigator' to claim the title in what was only their second appearance at the Spring Festival.

Latest success

It is the latest success for an increasingly formidable contesting outfit that continues to make a name for itself with its innovative project led approach, but which under the baton of their Welsh conductor has also secured the First Section West of England, National Championship of Great Britain and Welsh Open titles in the past year or so.

They will be joined in the Senior Cup in 2017 alongside impressive fellow qualifiers Goodwick Brass, Oldham (Lees) and Jackfield (Elcock Resien), whilst at the other end of the results table the sextet of Medway, 1st Old Boys, City of Bradford, Felling, Foresters Brass 2000 and Leicester Co-operative must set their sights on re-qualification.

Little doubt

There was little doubt in the minds of adjudicators David Thornton and Sandy Smith that Vinter's final major work had provided a stern challenge of technical and musical character for the 20 competitors on what turned out to be a thoroughly engaging contest.

"We had a fantastic day listening to a wonderful piece,"David told the audience before the announcement of the results. "It tested the bands in a number of ways; dynamics, sound, soloists (he made a special mention of the quality of euphonium playing on show) — even triple tonguing trombones.

It was a question of finding the drama in the music though — the subject matter told us all about that. Bands had to capture the musicality and the piece had to ooze that drama to work and work well."

Too bland

A little later the judges told 4BR that they had few problems sorting the bands out. "The best stood out thanks to intelligent approaches by conductors and good quality playing all round the stands,"Sandy said, before adding: "We had hoped that the overall standard of the contest would have been better though.

A number of performances were just too bland and lacked drama, pathos and heroism."

However, the Scot, who has put his head above the parapet in recent times with his strong views on contest test-piece suitability, was in no doubt that despite its age, Vinter's colourful musical seafaring portrait had proved its worth once again.

"It was an excellent choice for those with realistic aspirations to climb the Spring Festival ladder,"he said. "It gave them an opportunity to showcase their musicality on firm technical foundations. The piece may be over 40 years old, but it still takes some playing even now."

Classy musicality

The combination of classy musicality and solid technique was certainly something that they highlighted in their remarks of the winners.

"A real stamp of quality,"David wrote of Filton. "An excellent show! Bravo to all."Meanwhile, Sandy added: "This has 'film music' like drama."before rounding off his remarks by stating, "A fine ending to a really stylish performance full of detail."

Delight

Not surprisingly Filton's MD was delighted when 4BR finally caught up with him on Monday morning.

"That was perhaps the most complete performance the band has delivered on stage,"Tom Davoren said. "I loved working on the piece — and so did the players. It's easy to forget just how brilliant a composer Vinter was; but as soon as you explore the score you can see and hear his genius at work. It's a composition that has lost none of its musical or contesting relevance."

He added: "Amazingly it's the oldest piece we have worked on, but we still found it so fresh. The players rose to the challenge — especially Anthony Smith on euphonium and all the main soloists.

Having a settled band that enjoys the project led approach we work to is a great bonus. The players deserve all the credit and the break they can enjoy before we look towards the Wychavon contest and the rest of the year."

Substantive

Also with plenty to look forward to is Goodwick Brass, as they marked their Spring Festival debuts with a fine performance under MD Matthew Jenkins to take another substantive next step forward on their rise to top flight prominence.

A little earlier it was the bold Scots of Unison Kinneil conducted by Colin Mackenzie who set the initial marker off the number 3 draw to eventually finish sixth, before the youthful Oldham (Lees) under John Collins upped the James Cook ante with a spirited account that led the way at the halfway point of the contest.

Soon after though came a quartet of colourful renditions — each bringing that essential sense of drama out of the score in their different ways; the first coming from the confident midlanders of Jackfield (Elcock Reisen) under Simon Platford to finish fourth, followed immediately by Goodwick.

Then came the eventual champion with their classy account enhanced by the excellent contributions of all their main solo players — and especially 'Best Instrumentalist' award winner Anthony Smith on euphonium, before a vibrant East London Brass conducted by Jayne Murrill claimed the final spot in the top-six.

Plimsoll line

There was also a great deal to enjoy from just about every performance, although a number of bands failed to appreciate the idiosyncrasies of the Spanish Hall acoustic.

Some over-enthusiastic percussion and questionable tempos saw a number of renditions holed below the Plimsoll line, whilst some equally idiosyncratic interpretations of Vinter's score were also evident — with one or two MDs perhaps showing their unfamiliarity with the composer's intuitive but very specific scoring requirements.

That was certainly not the case with Filton Concert Brass though; as a band that despite hailing from a part of Bristol more renowned for its aviation industry, showed that it was also very much at home with its historic seafaring tradition too.

I loved working on the piece — and so did the players. It's easy to forget just how brilliant a composer Vinter was; but as soon as you explore the score you can see and hear his genius at workTom Davoren.

Results:

Venue: Spanish Hall
Test Piece: James Cook Circumnavigator (Gilbert Vinter)

Adjudicators: Sandy Smith & Dr David Thornton

1. Filton Concert Brass (Tom Davoren)*
2. Goodwick Brass (Matthew Jenkins)*
3. Oldham (Lees) (John Collins)*
4. Jackfield (Elcock Reisen) (Simon Platford)*
5. East London Brass (Jayne Murrill)
6. Unison Kinneil (Colin McKenzie)
7. Roberts Bakery (Simon Stonehouse)
8. Laganvale (Metal Technology) (Stephen Crooks)
9. Drighlington (John Roberts)
10. Bo'ness & Carriden (Andrew Duncan)
11. SPAL Sovereign Brass (Trevor Jones)
12. Tylorstown (Gary Davies)
13. Longridge (Mareika Gray)
14. Dalmellington (Richard Evans)
15. Medway (Melvin White)**
16. 1st Old Boys (Stephen Cairns)**
17. City of Bradford (Lee Skipsey)**
18. Felling (Chris Bentham)**
19. Foresters Brass 2000 (Jack Capstaff)**
20. Leicester Co-operative (Graham Jacklin)**

Best Instrumentalist: Anthony Smith (euphonium) — Filton Concert

*Promoted to Senior Cup
**Must re-qualify

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


wobplay

New additions to Wobplay releases

July 30 • A premiere release from the International Staff Band is joined by classic Cory, memories of the Masters and and Edward Gregson greatest hits.


NYBBS

Fun and friendship key ingredients to NYBBS success

July 29 • A fantastic week of music making in Perthshire was rounded off with a memorable triptych concert.


Red Admira

Red Admiral still open for late arrivals

July 29 • If you want to be part of the live-broadcast Red Admiral Music Academy Entertainment Contest then you still have time...


Edward Gregson

National study scores now available

July 29 • Study scores of Edward Gregson's 'Symphony in Two Movements' are now available for Studio Music.


Haverhill Silver Band - A Nightingale Sang... (an evening concert)

Saturday 2 August • Foakes Hall, Dunmow CM6 1DG


The Lindley Band - Parp and a Pint

Wednesday 6 August • 14a Holly Bank Road. Lindley. Huddersfield . West Yorkshire HD3 3 JE


Haverhill Silver Band - East Anglian Beer & Cider Festival

Sunday 24 August • St Edmundsbury Cathedral, Bury St Edmunds IP33 1QX


Haverhill Silver Band - Concert in Saffron Hall

Wednesday 27 August • Saffron Hall, Audley End Road, Saffron Walden, Essex CB11 4UH


Uckfield Concert Brass - Eastbourne Bandstand 1812 Concert

Wednesday 27 August • Eastbourne Bandstand, Lower Grand Parade, Eastbourne. BN21 3AD


Hathersage Band

July 30 • FRONT ROW CORNET (position negotiable). Hathersage Brass Band is a thriving, non-contesting community band. We enjoy our music making, play a wide variety of music and have a good gig schedule. Are you the right person to join our happy band?


Alder Valley Brass

July 30 • We are looking for a front row cornet player to join our ambitious, busy and sociable 2nd section band (national finalists 2023). We have a good blend of concerts, engagements and contests. Rehearsals Mondays and Thursdays 8-10pm in Farnham, Surrey


Cambrian Brass

July 30 • Heading to Aberystwyth University this September? . Join us on Friday evenings, just a short walk from campus, and be part of a growing band with exciting plans for the year ahead!


Andreas Kratz

Mus.B (hons)
Conductor, Adjudicator, Teacher


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd