*
banner

Brass band adjudication — simples...

If you think the current Brass in Concert adjudication system is complex, then spare a thought for the judges of yesteryear...

The judges at London 2014
 

A recent piece of correspondence to 4BR about the adjudication system currently being employed at the Brass in Concert Championship has seen us scrambling around in the history books to find out if such a ‘complex’ system of judging has ever been used before at any other major brass band contest in the UK.

http://www.4barsrest.com/comments/159.asp#.VKPBFCusUg8

Nothing new

Not surprisingly, you find that there is nothing new under the banding sun.

British Open

At the 1943 British Open, the three judges had to award separate marks for five different areas of performance on Beethoven’s ‘5th Symphony’:

Accuracy in Time Values and Notes (30 points)
Tone, Tune and Individual Intonation (50 points)
Rhythm, Phrasing, Pace and Continuity (40 points)
Balance, Blend, Ensemble (30 points)
Interpretation and General Effect (50 points)

The winners, Bickerhsaw Colliery gave ‘a masterly performance’, according to one adjudicator Henry Geehl — gaining a total of 194 marks.

Nationals

Much further back, at the 1901 National Championships of Great Britain, bands were scored in each of 10 different categories to give their overall total.

These included marks for: Ensemble; Style; Intonation (20 points each) — as well as individual marks for soprano, solo cornet, horns, baritones, trombones, euphoniums and basses (10 points with added extra points for best soprano, solo cornet and euphonium).

The winners, Lee Mount gained a remarkable 127 points on ‘Gems from Sullivan’s Opera No 3’.

At the 1943 British Open, the three judges had to award separate marks for five different areas of performance on Beethoven’s ‘5th Symphony’4BR

Simples...

It makes individual marks for Music Quality of Performance (A&B); Programme Content; Entertainment & Presentation (A&B) seem positively simple…

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Wellington

New Zealand reflects on National boost

August 2 • New Zealand banding returned to the post Covid-19 contesting stage with a sense of rejuvenation — led by a new generation of young players.


Bolsover

Communal approach brings Covid success for Bolsover

August 2 • Extensive preparations and communal support gives the Bolsover International Brass Band Summer School a clean bill of health as well as a huge musical boost.


Butlins

Cash and carry at Butlin's in 2022

July 31 • There is plenty of prize money to win at the Butlin's Open Brass Band Festival in January — with individuals, ensembles and bands able to carry off big cash prizes.


Bolsover

Friday night is music night at Bolsover Summer School

July 30 • The Bolsover International Brass Band Summer School has been a huge success this year — with delegates and tutors overcoming Covid and the weather to enjoying their music making.


Regent Hall Concerts - Trafalgar Brass

Friday 6 August • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London SE7 8RE


Epping Forest Band - Proms on the Green

Sunday 8 August • On the green outside the Epping Forest District Council Civic Offices CM16 4BZ


Regent Hall Concerts - Arc Brass

Friday 13 August • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London . SE7 8RE


Regent Hall Concerts - The Wind Ensemble of the Band of the RAF Regiment

Friday 20 August • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London . SE7 8RE


Regent Hall Concerts - The Brass Ensemble of the Central Band of the RAF

Friday 27 August • Charlton House. Charlton Road. London . SE7 8RE


Deepcar Brass Band

August 2 • Musical Director required from September onwards who will help to continue developing and motivating the band.4th section band next year we are keen to regain 3rd section status. We are open to discussions with conductors of varying ranges of experience.


Chapeltown Silver Prize Band

August 2 • MUSICAL DIRECTOR, we invite applications from enthusiastic, hardworking, motivated individuals, who will challenge and further develop the success of the band. Based North Sheffield, 5 mins from M1 jct 35/36, with a sensible balance of concerts/contests.


Lydney Band

August 1 • Vacancies exist for a TROMBONE and an Eb BASS to strengthen the team. We are a 3rd section band (West of England), based in the Forest of Dean, Glos. Rehearsal - Friday evenings. Good travel links from Gloucester, South Wales and South Gloucestershire.


David Hirst

MA, B.Ed (Hons), LTCL
Conductor, adjudicator and arranger


               

 © 2021 4barsrest.com Ltd