*
banner

Brass band adjudication — simples...

If you think the current Brass in Concert adjudication system is complex, then spare a thought for the judges of yesteryear...

The judges at London 2014
 

A recent piece of correspondence to 4BR about the adjudication system currently being employed at the Brass in Concert Championship has seen us scrambling around in the history books to find out if such a ‘complex’ system of judging has ever been used before at any other major brass band contest in the UK.

http://www.4barsrest.com/comments/159.asp#.VKPBFCusUg8

Nothing new

Not surprisingly, you find that there is nothing new under the banding sun.

British Open

At the 1943 British Open, the three judges had to award separate marks for five different areas of performance on Beethoven’s ‘5th Symphony’:

Accuracy in Time Values and Notes (30 points)
Tone, Tune and Individual Intonation (50 points)
Rhythm, Phrasing, Pace and Continuity (40 points)
Balance, Blend, Ensemble (30 points)
Interpretation and General Effect (50 points)

The winners, Bickerhsaw Colliery gave ‘a masterly performance’, according to one adjudicator Henry Geehl — gaining a total of 194 marks.

Nationals

Much further back, at the 1901 National Championships of Great Britain, bands were scored in each of 10 different categories to give their overall total.

These included marks for: Ensemble; Style; Intonation (20 points each) — as well as individual marks for soprano, solo cornet, horns, baritones, trombones, euphoniums and basses (10 points with added extra points for best soprano, solo cornet and euphonium).

The winners, Lee Mount gained a remarkable 127 points on ‘Gems from Sullivan’s Opera No 3’.

At the 1943 British Open, the three judges had to award separate marks for five different areas of performance on Beethoven’s ‘5th Symphony’4BR

Simples...

It makes individual marks for Music Quality of Performance (A&B); Programme Content; Entertainment & Presentation (A&B) seem positively simple…

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


UniTE

Result: 2026 Band Supplies Scottish Challenge

November 22 • Unite Scotland Kinneil once again repels the challengers to its title in Perth


childs

Childs showstopper on Mealor Concerto

November 21 • David Childs' recent performance of Paul Mealor's 'Euphonium Concerto' has once again brought critical acclaim.


Band supplies

A huge field of thanks for Band Supplies Scottish Challenge in Perth

November 21 • Sponsors thank bands for what promises to be a packed day of great brass band contesting in Perth at the Band Supplies Scottish Challenge Shield.


Open Door policy gains plaudits for National Youth performers

November 21 • An ensemble from the National Youth Brass Band of Great Britain have played their part in the 300th anniversary celebrations of the Church with the ever open door in heart of London...


Bilton Silver Rugby Band - Bilton Silver President's Concert

Friday 27 November • St George's Church, St Johns Avenue, Rugby CV22 5HR


West Yorkshire Police Band - Mid Yorkshire Breast Cancer Support

Saturday 28 November • Cluntergate Centre, Horbury WF4 5DA


The Hepworth Band - Leeds Best of Brass 2026/27

Saturday 28 November • Pudsey Civic Hall, Dawsons Corner, Pudsey LS28 5ED


The Hepworth Band - Christmas Brass & Voices

Saturday 5 December • Thornhill Parish Church, Church Lane, Thornhill, Dewsbury WF12 0JZ


Newstead Brass - The Snowman - Live

Saturday 5 December • Forest Town Arena. Clipstone Road West, Forest Town. Mansfield NG19 0EE


Brunel Brass Organisation

November 20 • Brunel Brass is looking for a Eb or Bb BASS to complete the band. Challenging for promotion to the Championship Section in 2027 and achieving our highest ever result at the British Open Senior Trophy in 2026, it's an exciting time to join the band!


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Front Row Cornet player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Eb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Jenny Gartside

Bsc Hons
Jeweller, brass band themed jewellery and pin badges


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd