*
banner

US Open articulates adjudication philosophy

The US Open Brass Band Championships share their their vision on adjudication and will provide examples following this year's championships.

 

The U.S. Open is now in its ninth year as the only entertainment-style brass band contest in North America, and although some of the details of the adjudication process have been refined and revised over the years, the basic concepts and goals remain the same. The contest committee often receives questions about the judging system, and in an effort to clarify the method, philosophy, and judging technique, we offer following information.

Achievement and Innovation
The basis for evaluation by the adjudicators is the achievement of the performers as displayed that day. It is the sum of the two elements of what they present and how well they perform it. All judges evaluate both of these elements. Each band’s presentation is numerically rewarded to the degree that it is successfully performed.

The contest encourages and rewards innovations and artistry for skillful presentations of new compositions and arrangements for brass band, as well as for unique and successful entertainment devices used during the performance.

Criteria-based assessment focuses on the positive
The foundational method of the scoring system focuses primarily on the positive qualities of the performance, rather than a listing of technical errors. Using a criteria-based reference system, it is meant to guide all bands—regardless of their stylistic choices or contest experience—to the qualities they must achieve and display to receive a range of numerical scores.

For example, in the 100-point Music Category, scores in the range of 90-100 are considered Superior and must satisfy the highest standards in musical qualities such as expression, dynamics, pitch, rhythmic accuracy, tempo control, and many others. The category of Excellent has a numerical range of 70-89 points and recognizes a high level of musical qualities but with some inconsistencies and failings in one or more of these areas. Bands receiving scores in the Music Category of 69 and below are categorized as Good and display failings and shortcomings in many areas, perhaps being classed as average or below.

The 25-point Entertainment caption has similar groupings of quality assessments, and evaluates criteria such as creativity, imagination, variety, audience appeal, emotional range, and effective communication with the audience: the brass band equivalent of “The X Factor.”

Thus, each adjudicator could award a maximum of 125 points for an absolutely perfect performance. Judges’ scores are added together to arrive at the ranking and rating for each band. Since bands are ranked in the order of their achievement, judges avoid creating ties in either category.

Technology adds more clarification
While each band is performing, the judges record their comments into digital recorders, making both positive and negative observations, allowing themselves to react to both the musical and entertainment qualities presented.

Each band receives its recordings at the end of the contest, so that they can understand how the judges may have arrived at their decision, as well as to learn what things the critical ears of the judges found to be notable. This information can help bands with future preparations.

Judge for yourself
This year the U.S. Open committee will publish on its Web site some highlights and snippets of the judges’ recorded comments, thus allowing the entire brass band community to get a better idea of the sorts of things that judges are listening for, and to help follow their thought processes as they evaluate the bands’ performances. We believe this to be a first for the brass band community, and we hope that it will help further the development of brass band adjudication throughout the world. These recordings will be available at www.usopenbrass.org

Submitted by Dallas Niermeyer, Vice-President and Adjudication Coordinator, Brass Bands International

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Desford Colliery

Result: 2025 National Championship of Great Britain

October 12 • Desford surprise the favourites to claim a fifth National title success.


ISB and Fodens

Friday night Gregson spotlights

October 10 • You will be spoilt for a Gregson choice between the ISB and Ian Bousfield and Foden's and Mike Lovatt if you are in London this evening.


World of Brass

Make sure you pick up the latest releases at the Albert Hall

October 10 • The World of Brass trade stand will be packed with musical goodies — from the study score of 'Symphony in Two Movements' to the latest releases from Cory, Tredegar, Brett Baker and the ISB.


Edward Gregson

The composer's viewpoint

October 10 • Edward Gregson talks about 'Symphony in Two Movements' to Dr Robert Childs — as well as previewing it on Radio 3 before the contest day itself.


Regent Hall Concerts - Stately Brass Quintet

Friday 10 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Academy Symphonic Brass

Friday 10 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Hathersage Band - Hathersage Village Autumn Concert

Saturday 11 October • Hathersage Methodist Church, Main Road, Hathersage S32 1BB S32 1BB


Contest: National Brass Band Championships of Great Britain

Saturday 11 October • The Royal Albert Hall, Kensington Gore, South Kensington, London SW7 2AP


Regent Hall Concerts - Regent Hall Band of the Salvation Army

Tuesday 14 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Stretford Band

October 11 • Stretford Band (Manchester) has a terrific new MD. Now it needs you! We need bass, trombone and percussion but will welcome anyone who wants to play popular music without the stress of competing. Any ability any age.. Hope to see you soon.


Audley Brass

October 10 • Audley Brass (First Section National Finalists 2025) are seeking a first class PRINCIPAL EUPHONIUM. We have some very exciting events coming up including 3 epic beer festival nights and Wychavon Festival of Brass entertainment contest.


Chinnor Silver

October 8 • Our community band is meeting again 11am Monday 13th after completing our first gig.. We would love you to join us.We are a band of mixed abilities and welcome ALL players.. Blowing with us will not impact on your own band and its all free.


Howard J Evans

MA (Dist), Mus.B (hons), ARCM (hons), LRAM, LTCL, PGCE
Conductor, composer, arranger, tutor and pianist


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd