*
banner

ABBA accuse Mead of mysticism

The Association of Brass Band Adjudicators has launched an astonishing 'Mythical' attack on Steven Mead.

ABBA
 

The Association of Brass Band Adjudicator’s has reopened the debate over adjudication standards, with an astonishing attack on Steven Mead in an article which was sent to 4BR and has since appeared on the ABBA website.

Mythical Meetings

Under the headline, 'Mythical Meetings!!', ABBA Secretary, C Brian Buckley states that he is 'at a loss' to understand why the euphonium star asserted that he had agreed a meeting between himself and his organisation.

Inconceivable

He goes on further to write that since his ‘untimely and largely rhetorical comments’ first appeared on his website, Steven has not contacted him either by phone e-mail or snail mail and that it is '...inconceivable that he has prepared copious information comparing a range of adjudicating systems.'

Initial offer

As reported previously on 4BR, ABBA had initially offered to meet and discuss the issues raised by Steven Mead in his article, 'Time for Change', the statement published both on the 4BR website and their own site, concluding that, "... meeting with Steven Mead at this stage would be both unproductive and premature."

No approach

It now appears that ABBA states that no subsequent approach, formal or otherwise, was made by Steven Mead, although 4BR has seen copies of e-mails sent by the Whitburn conductor to the organisation through Brian Buckley dated the 15th September (just three days after the contest), which was subsequently resent 10 days later.

Did write

Speaking to 4BR, Steven stated: "I did write to ABBA through Brian on the 15th September and again by resending the original e-mail 10 days later after receiving no reply.

"I also agreed that I would attend a meeting with ABBA, most notably during an audio interview on 4BR which was undertaken five days after the contest. Brian had mentioned to me on the phone, the date of October 7th, which I initally reserved but explianed I would prefer to speak with Derek Braodbent (ABBA Chairman) first."

Collating information

Steven added: "As I had no replay to my e-mails I presumed they’s changed their mind, but I carried on collating information in respect to my concerns as I clearly stated I would."


ABBA article:


The published article from the ABBA Secretary reads as follows:

'Mythical Meetings!!

As Secretary of ABBA, I am at a loss to understand why Steven Mead continues to assert that a meeting had been agreed between himself and ABBA.

As far as I am aware, I am the only member of the Executive Committee that has been in direct contact with Steven Mead since he published his untimely and largely rhetorical comments in the article (subsequently and rapidly amended by him), that appeared on his personal website following the conclusion of the "British Open" event at Symphony Hall, Birmingham in September 2009.

This article was obviously influenced by Steven's intense disappointment at the placing of the band he had prepared for and directed at this event.

Given the nature of the content of his article, I telephoned Steven late on Sunday morning, the day after the "British Open".

He expressed discomfort about the possibility of meeting the Executive Committee of ABBA, indicating that he would only want to meet the Chairperson of ABBA, a surprising disclosure given the original text of his article.

Since he was busy preparing to leave the UK later that afternoon to fulfil a series of overseas engagements and would not be returning to the UK for several weeks, it was left with Steven to contact me on his return. We could then discuss the possibility of arranging a meeting between himself and ABBA should this be considered a productive step forward!

To date, Steven has not contacted me neither by mobile or fixed telephone, e-mail or snail-mail. So I find it quite remarkable that such a busy and obviously well organised professional person publicly contends that he has written to ABBA twice without reply.

Following our September Sunday morning telephone discussion; I was expecting him to make contact. This has not happened. Likewise, I have not been made aware of any other ABBA member having has contact with Steven on this matter.

Without having made arrangements for such a meeting to take place, it is inconceivable that (according to his most recent commentary on this matter, as published on his website), he has "prepared copious information comparing a range of adjudicating systems from many different spheres of music contests", — all this in preparation for a mythical meeting between himself and ABBA that could not take place until he had contacted ABBA.

He also highlights that he has prepared "considerable analytical data from systems used for marching bands, ice skating and gymnastic events". Perhaps these assessments are more appropriate for application to visual, rather than aurally assessed competitions.

Disappointingly, much of Steven's recently published comments are again largely rhetoric in style, being short on factual statements, but littered with rather imaginative phrases.

The role of ABBA is not to address changes that Steven contends are "needed with regard to the current set up of the Brass band movement's contests", but merely to address the adjudication process — in January 2003 ABBA carried out an exercise on criteria based marking at their Annual CPD session.

It would be helpful if Steven could let ABBA have sight of his evidence that supports his contention that the adjudication process can be improved to benefit all participants and those who administer and officiate at competitive events.

It would also be a constructive initiative if Steven could obtain permission from "the leading lights in the brass band world" who have provided him "some quite superb systems", to release their identity to ABBA so that discussions leading to meaningful conclusion can then ensue.

Not surprisingly ABBA is wary of creating an illusion of progress, but are committed to making genuine progress.

C Brian Buckley
Secretary – ABBA

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Hannah Peel

Radio: Brass Banding with Hannah Peel

April 25 • The first episode of the much anticipated new Radio 3 brass band series starts on Sunday with a musical trip to Norway...


Music

Own choice works revealed for Stavanger

April 25 • A wide ranging selection of major test-piece works will be performed in Stavanger.


NYBBGB

National Youth Band sells out in Halifax

April 25 • The National Youth Band of Great Britain will be joined by the British Army Brass Band for a sell out concert in Halifax this weekend.


bRADOFRD

Bradford boost for Black Dyke Band

April 25 • The Yorkshire champion's involvement in Bradford's celebration as the UK City of Culture on Radio 2 has gained widespread plaudits.


Regent Hall Concerts - The Central Band of the Royal Air Force

Friday 25 April • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London. . W1C2DJ


Newstead Brass - Under Gaia

Saturday 26 April • Mansfield Palace Theatre. Leeming Street . Mansfield. Nottinghamshire NG18 1NG


Newstead Brass - St George's Day Celebration

Sunday 27 April • St Wilfrid's Church, Church Street, Kirkby In Ashfield NG17 8LA


Regent Hall Concerts - Royal Greenwich Brass Band

Sunday 4 May • St Alfege Church. Greenwich Church Street SE10 9BJ


Contest: European Brass Band Championshiips

Friday 9 May • Konzerthaus, SandvigÃ¥ 1, 4007 Stavanger, Norway


Dobcross Silver Band

April 24 • Great opportunity for a PERCUSSIONIST to join this already talented section in what is already a band with a full brass section. We are looking to enhance our percussion section as we prepare for Nationals in September . Enjoyable playing and social band!


Hathersage Band

April 24 • SECOND TROMBONE. Hathersage Brass Band is a thriving non-contesting community band. We enjoy making music and have a comprehensive gig schedule. Are you the right person to join our happy band?


Chinnor Silver

April 22 • Our COMMUNITY BAND are recommencing rehearsals on 28th Monday at 11am in our bandroom and we would love you to join us.. We welcome players of all abilities who just fancy a friendly fun blow with cake and coffee thrown in.. Its all free so join us.


Julian Bright


Conductor, Compere/MC, Cornet Soloist


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd