*
banner

Snobbish views on brass bands not dead

An article in MUSO magazine reveals that some age old snobbish views on brass bands are still alive and well in the metropolitan orchestral world.

Barbican Brass
 

If you ever wondered how some people in the orchestral world view brass bands, then the November issue of MUSO magazine is quite enlightening.

Supportive

In an interesting and supportive article by Abi Bliss on the Barbican Brass quintet, which comprises Philip Cobb, the recently appointed joint principal trumpet of the London Symphony Orchestra, a fellow member of the group highlights what he refers to as a 'less positive aspect' of brass bands.

...even Philip Cobb has been subject to ill informed 'mickey taking' for not knowing the orchestral repertoire as well as those brought up solely in the medium4BR

Ongoing problem

Trombonist Steven Haynes, a former member of the National Youth Brass Band of Great Britain, talks about what he perceives is a ongoing problem.

"I think musically, it’s a shame that brass bands don’t listen to other kinds of music a bit more. I certainly learned a lot once I got to music college in terms of style, which I’d not learnt in the brass band."

Advocate

Despite that misgiving, Haynes is a passionate advocate of brass banding, and calls it a 'proving ground' that gives its performers the edge over orchestral counterparts in 'invaluable training' in terms of stamina and sight reading.

Interestingly he also reveals his impression that there is also a form of musical 'snobbery' in what the author calls the metropolitan music world.

Snobbery

"...there’s a jokey snobbery element that I get all the time," he says, before showing a steely resolve to show the shallowness of those perpetrating it by using the examples of Maurice Murphy, Ian Bousefield, Rod Franks and Philip Cobb as proof that the banding movement has produced its fair share of undisputed world class performers.

Mickey taking

Although he says that respect is forthcoming if the orchestral world finds out you come from a Yorkshire or Lancashire banding background, he also reveals that even Philip Cobb has been subject to ill informed 'mickey taking' for not knowing the orchestral repertoire as well as those brought up solely in the medium.

Pretty quick

However, Steven one again shows his support for both his friend and fellow brass bander by adding, "...he plays the trumpet better than most other people, so it doesn’t matter. He’s so musical, he can figure it out for himself pretty quick."

The article can be found in the Oct/Nov (issue 43) of MUSO Magazine or go to www.musolife.com

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


David Bremner

2025 RNCM International Brass Band Festival: Interview with David Bremner

January 24 • We chat to the New Zealand trombone star and conductor about his appearance at the festival as a soloist and at the helm with Brighouse & Rastrick.


Mark Bousie

2025 RNCM International Brass Band Festival: Interview with Mark Bousie

January 24 • We talk to Mark Bousie who will be leading the talented students of the Junior RNCM Brass Band in an ambitious programme — including two world premieres on Saturday afternoon.


Superbrass

Superbrass Saturday: Leviathan (Paul Denegri arr. Tom Barton)

January 24 • A great concert work brings a big beast of the ocean to life in a fantastic arrangement.


Doodles

New year resolutions to meet for Doodles Mouthpiece replating

January 24 • If you made a New Year's resolution to get your mouthpiece fixed for the Areas this year then get in touch with Dave Houghton pronto...


The Hepworth Band - Hepworth Band New Year Celebration Concert

Sunday 26 January • Christ Church, New Mill, Holmfirth HD97ER


Dobcross Silver Band - Hammonds Band

Sunday 26 January • c/o Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross Saddleworth OL3 5AD


Regent Hall Concerts - The Band of the Grenadier Guards

Friday 31 January • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Contest: Norwegian National Brass Band Championships

Friday 7 February • Grieghallen, Bergen, N-5015. N-5015


Regent Hall Concerts - Junior Guildhall Brass Band

Friday 7 February • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


North SomerCommunity Brass

January 24 • North Somerset Community Brass are looking to appoint a new MD with immediate effect. We are an enthusiastic non contesting band, looking for someone to lead us and make their mark on the band. We meet on a Friday evening near Weston super Mare.


Haverhill Silver Band

January 23 • Haverhill Silver Band (champ section) seeks PRINCIPAL CORNET. This is a superb opportunity to lead East Anglia's premier brass band to the area contest, the Senior Cup, Whit Friday and beyond. Applications to join after the area contest also considered.


HYDE BAND

January 22 • WE HAVE PLAYER VACANCIES (POSITIONS NEGOTIABLE) Come and join our friendly First Section Band based in the New forest, and enjoy working with our Musical Director: Ben Halstead on a varied programme of concerts and contest.


Duncan A. Beckley

BA, MA
Conductor, adjudicator, band trainer and teacher


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd