Take 5
A quintet of great Fireworks displays

Remember Remember the 5th of November — with five great recordings of Elgar Howarth's iconic pyrotechnic test-piece.

They say you should ‘Remember, Remember the 5th of November’, but it’s also worth noting that this week saw the 85th birthday of Elgar Howarth, the composer who lit a bonfire fuse under years of tradition with his very own box of ‘Fireworks’ in 1975.

His brilliantly inventive version of ‘The Young Person’s Guide to the Brass Band’ caused an explosion at the British Open that is hard to imagine nowadays.


There were conductors who swore they wouldn’t compete in Manchester after they opened their scores and were faced with musical writing that they didn’t understand or appreciate.

Traditionalists thought he was taking the mickey in noting that his ‘theme’ (wonderful as it was) was attributed to his ‘nom de guerre’ W. Hogarth Lear.

Many listeners didn’t either, and there were boos aimed at Howarth when he walked from the adjudicator’s box towards the stage at the famous King’s Hall at Belle Vue before the announcement of the results. 

Traditionalists thought he was taking the mickey in noting that his ‘theme’ (wonderful as it was) was attributed to his ‘nom de guerre’ W. Hogarth Lear.

The composer


However, ‘Fireworks’  certainly had its fans: Eric Ball no less saying that it had “a sardonic wit, which I liked enormously – a sort of French sparkle to it”. 

The great George Thompson called it “the work of a genius”, whilst understandably, Richard Evans, the winning conductor with Wingates Temperance on the day said it was, “…a great piece – it stretched the bands – there was nowhere to hide, everyone had to play their part.”

It still divides opinion, even today - although 45 years after its premiere it now seems somewhat stereotypically dated in many aspects.


It does however contain remarkable elements of inspiration, with the seamless transition in the fugato finale from an Allegro con brio  of crotchet 138  to a gloriously rich chorale at minim 72  a majestic, almost imperceptibly smooth Rolls Royce power surge that takes the breath away if mastered correctly. 

 the seamless transition in the fugato finale from an Allegro con brio  of crotchet 138  to a gloriously rich chorale at minim 72  a majestic, almost imperceptibly smooth Rolls Royce power surge that takes the breath away if mastered correctly. 

Oddly, it hasn’t been recorded on many occasions since it was first heard 45 years ago – especially in its narrated form.  That’s a huge pity – as despite its stylistic limitations it remains a work of huge significance – and fun. 

These are our five in chronological order to add to your play lists if you can find them.

Wingates Temperance (1976)
Fireworks and Sparklers
Conductor: Richard Evans 
Grosvenor Records: GRS 1045

Recorded just a few months after their Belle Vue triumph, this may sound incredibly dated in technical proficiency and tonal quality by today’s standards, but that doesn’t really tell the whole story.

Richard Evans’ interpretation is laced with the dry ‘sardonic wit’ Eric Ball talked about; light, waspish and acidic even if it is sometime lost in the wide solo and vibrato sounds. 

At just under 16 minutes he captures the essence of each section and individual portrait – warts and all, bringing the music to life with a touch of rough-edged élan. 

Interestingly, the personnel on the recording (produced by Bram Gay to which the work is dedicated) contained a certain Allan Withington on bumper-up and John Golland on glockenspiel – musicians who made their mark in different ways in the years that followed.

Grimethorpe Colliery Band (1976)
Grimethorpe Special
with Besses o’ th’ Barn
Conductor: Elgar Howarth
Narrator: Valerie Solti 
Decca Headline Recording: Head 14

A truly remarkable recording – and not just as it’s framed in its true context with narration provided by Valarie Solti, who guides us through the score in the best traditions of a BBC ‘Listen with Mother’ presenter.  She’s also wonderfully sexy.

The opening minute bubbles with the sound of the brass orchestra ‘warming up’ before Lady ‘S’ leads us by the hand on our journey of exploration.

Howarth revels in a personal interpretation that’s nonchalantly academic; laced with a languid, passionate stylistic pulse that draws vivid contrasts of timbre and colour to bring the work to life. 

The quicker elements fizz with joyful playfulness and the finale (Besses join at this point) is paced perfectly (the gear change sumptuous) to a glorious baroque close. 

It is 18 minutes of definitive 1970’s magic.

Cory (1982)
Highlights of the 1982 Brass Band Festival
Conductor: Major Arthur Kenney
Chandos Digital Recordings:  BBRD 1017/8

Cory had been crowned National Champion playing ‘Contest Music’  by Wilfred Heaton less than 24 hours before they took the stage for this performance. 

Now Major Arthur Kenney and has band produced something almost equally fantastic with their own-choice European Championship selection (and they must have had a few sore heads) on a work of diametric polarity. 

In the end it didn’t do enough to win the contest (it was placed second as they came runner-up overall to Black Dyke) but it’s still quite a show despite the odd powder burn from an errant sparkler or two around the stands.

Kenney’s glorious reading oozes stylistic brilliance; the blue touch paper lit by the impish MD from his box of tricks and sent into the Albert Hall air as if he had packed each firework with his own alchemist gunpowder mix to create the effects he wanted to delight the audience.

It’s a true virtuoso performance – and the crowd go bonkers.

Eikanger Bjorsvik Musikklag (1999)
Conductor: Elgar Howarth 
Doyen Recordings: DOYCD088

This is Elgar Howarth at the very peak of his banding powers on a CD release that retains an authentic seal of excellence to this day (there is also remarkable performance on it from Hakan Hardenberger).

The MD eschews any pretence to instil a sense of enforced wit or overt academic strictures, and simply allows the music to speak for itself. 

The clarity of the thought process revealed is startling – the colours rich and vivid, the brilliance of the individual and solo elements exploding into view in front of your eyes before fading away into an inky black sky.

Eikanger are inspired; both nuanced and subtle as well as febrile and power laden – from leviathan tubas to ‘Catherine Wheel’ soprano whirling away in leading a finale that builds and builds before employing a turbo-charge boost of smoothness to an epic close.

To enjoy and purchase: http://https://wobplay.com/site/view?asset_id=DOYCD088

Cory (2015)
Neglected Treasures
Conductor: Philip Harper
Narrator: Morgan Jones
Doyen Recordings: DOYCD355

Almost 40 years after Grimethorpe’s recording comes Cory’s polished showcase approach under Philip Harper. 

It is a bit of a curate’s pyrotechnic egg - undoubtedly brilliant (the opening cornet cadenza in particular), but somehow not quite the sum of its parts.

In comparison to the smooth silkiness of Valerie Solti, the narration sounds a bit like a Welsh local authority ‘Fireworks Night’ announcement - detached from the action behind a microphone and added on at a later date.  It’s not quite Richard Burton and 'War of the Worlds'.  

Despite that, the playing sparkles and fizzes throughout, with each firework element doing the job intended, even if it’s all rather at arm’s length behind a recording safety barrier, when you really want to get a bit closer to the danger of it all for that extra thrill. 

To enjoy and purchase: https://wobplay.com/site/view?asset_id=DOYCD355

Support us for less than a cup of coffee...

4BR wants to ensure that the brass band movement remains vibrant and relevant. We also want to be able to question, challenge and critically examine those who run and play in it, producing high quality journalism that informs as well as entertains our readers.

So if like us you value a strong, independent perspective on the brass band world - then why not consider becoming a supporter and help make our future and that of a burgeoning brass band movement more secure.

So one less cappuccino then?

Support us    

Perth Festival of the Arts - BBC Big Band at Perth Festival of the Arts

Wednesday 25 May • Perth Concert Hall, Mill Street, Perth PH1 5HZ

Grimethorpe Colliery Band - Brassed Off Live at The Royal Albert Hall

Wednesday 25 May • Royal Albert Hall, Kensington Gore, South Kensington, London. SW7 2AP SW7 2AP

Perth Festival of the Arts - Opera Bohemia - Madama Butterfly

Thursday 26 May • Perth Theatre, Mill Street, Perth PH1 5HZ

Perth Festival of the Arts - Cross Trust Artists of the Year

Thursday 26 May • St Matthew's Church, Tay Street, Perth PH1 5LQ

Perth Festival of the Arts - The Voice of Desire

Friday 27 May • St John's Kirk of Perth, St John's Place, Perth PH1 5SZ

Derwent Brass

May 25 • PRINCIPAL EEb TUBA. Derwent Brass (Championship Section, Midlands) are seeking a Principal EEb Tuba - could it be you? We rehearse from our own facilitiy with a fully attended rehearsal just once a week - Thurs 20:00 - 22:00 (increased prior contests).

Garforth Brass

May 24 • Garforth Brass, a traditional brass band organisation, currently including a friendly 3rd section contesting band, concert band, and training band invites interested players to come along and see what we have to offer at your level.

Garforth Brass

May 24 • Garforth Brass, a traditional brass band organisation, currently including friendly 3rd section contesting band, concert band and learners band has vacancies for cornet players (position negotiable) to complete the team for contesting and concerts.

David Frame

Bass/Tenor Trombone Player, Adjudicator (Member of AoBBA) Occasional Conductor


 © 2022 4barsrest.com Ltd