2013 Spring Festival — Senior Trophy - retrospective

John James looks back on a contest won by Newtongrane — a band that has been on a high and low journey of its own of late.

A new high for Nitten...

With all the recent uplifting banding news coming out of Scotland seemingly centred on the admirable development of its grass roots structure, it’s easy to forget that there has also been a quiet renaissance in the fortunes for some of its senior bands too.

None more so than Newtongrange, who have experienced both the highs as well as the lows of contesting existence over the last few years.


Little wonder the current batch of players enjoyed themselves so much after they claimed the Senior Trophy on Eric Ball’s iconic ‘Journey into Freedom’, to add to the First Section Scottish Championship title they won earlier in the year.

From representing their nation at the European Championships in 2006, to being unable to take part in the Scottish Championship less than 12 months later – ‘Nitten’, as they are known colloquially north of the border, has experienced one heck of a ‘Journey’ of their own of late.

Lee Skipsey
The Newtongrange MD celebrates with the trophy


Directed with controlled brio by their newly appointed MD, Lee Skipsey, it was a victory borne of intelligence, confidence and musicality; virtues that were certainly needed in a contest that impressed adjudicators Simone Rebello and Lynda Nicholson sat in the box at the back of the Disneyesque surroundings of the Spanish Hall.

Eric Ball’s 1967 National test piece may have lost a few of its sharpest technical teeth over the last 46 years, but it has still retained the ability to sink its gnashers into the backside of any conductor who tries to take unwarranted liberties with its sublime musicality.

Self inflicted

The bands that were eventually found at the bottom end of the results table tended to be victims of self inflicted wounds – mainly through high minor error counts, poor ensemble, balance and dynamics, inexperience and nerves.

Thankfully, not one MD really tried to kid either the audience (and there was a good crowd in all day) or the judges, that they alone had found the Rosetta Stone secret to unlocking a hitherto unique reading of what really is a pretty straightforward and very familiar score.

No turn

Certainly not Lee Skipsey with Newtongrange, who shaped a coherent interpretation that kept both dynamics and tempos in check, allowed warmth and balance to permeate the ensemble and was delivered with assured technical confidence.

‘Nitten’ has stolen a real march on rivals by signing up one of the most exciting and talented young conductors in banding as their visiting professional MD.

There may not have been the trademark 180 degree turn to face the audience on the final chord, but from the feroce opening to the esaltato finish, the City of Bradford conductor directed with such an inherent understanding of the score that he could have conducted the final few bars with his eyes closed instead.

On this classy form the combination will be one of the real favourites to claim the First Section National title in Cheltenham in September.

Impressive qualifiers Laganvale (Metal Technology)


Joining them in the Senior Cup in 2014 though will be the impressive trio of Laganvale (Metal Technology), Camborne and East London Brass.

The Northern Irish band revelled in the music under the baton of Trevor Carter, with the wonderful Dessie Neill showing just why he is so well respected as a top class principal cornet on both sides of the Irish Sea, with his beautifully shaped delivery of the central love theme to claim the ‘Best Instrumentalist’ award.

It was expressive cornet playing of rare quality that formed the core of an equally impressive overall performance from a band that is a welcome (if all too rare) visitor to these shores.


Meanwhile, John Berryman’s clearly defined musical understanding of Eric Ball’s writing was certainly to the fore with Camborne’s lovingly shaped performance in coming third, with his ability to build the layers and tension in the lead into the final esaltato section, a mini masterclass of musicality.

There was just as much to enjoy with East London Brass, who rounded off the contest with tastefully textured account under Jayne Murrill that provided further evidence of the growing maturity as a top flight force. 

It really was a model of good ensemble husbandry from start to finish.

Understanding form in third for Camborne

Not quite

The confidence shown by both Drighlington and Sovereign Brass in filling the remaining top six places was obvious. 

Bold and purposeful, their slightly more robust ensemble sounds may not have been quite what the judges were looking for on the day, although their technical proficiency was as good as any of the qualifiers.

Lack of delicacy

With the Spanish Hall not the most forgiving place to try and show lip bursting muscle, the bands that tried to make a over forceful impact at the opening got caught out somewhat. 

Thelack of delicacy in the allegro scherzando waltz in particular  (with its opening three bars all on first valve for solo cornets) saw more errant chips than could be found on the pavement outside the nearest fish bar on the Golden Mile.

Still, it must have been difficult for the judges to separate out the solid midfield finishers, with the more refined understanding of the score, especially from the likes of Archie Hutchison (Dalmellington) and Russell Gray (Oldham Lees) balanced against the youthful gusto of Darren Hawkin (St Dennis) and John Ward (Jackfield). The margins between the 7th and 14th were small.

East London Brass
A textured qualification finish for East London Brass


Where some bands are enjoying the highs of contesting life, others are invariably enduring a few lows, so there should be a special mention to Hatfield Colliery (who were made up of players signed from three bands to be able to compete).

Stan Lippeatt did a wonderful job on the day; stepping in to help his friend Graham O’Connor who is recovering from a spell of ill health. 

His obvious enthusiasm, understanding and encouragement ensured the band gave a very creditable performance to end 16th.

You were left hoping that the band, Stan and Graham will be making their own journey back here for many more years to come.

John James

Northop Silver Band - Christmas Concert with Kirsty Abbotts

Sunday 3 December • St Eurgain & St Peter, Church Road, Northop CH7 6BQ

Boarshurst Silver Band - Littleborough Band

Sunday 3 December • Boarshurst Band Club. Greenbridge Lane. Greenfield. Oldham OL3 7EW

Garforth Brass - Garforth Community Choir

Wednesday 6 December • St James the Great,. Manston,. Crossgates, . Leeds,. LS15 8JB LS15 8JB

Longridge Band - Christmas Concert

Saturday 9 December • Longridge Civic Hall, Calder Avenue, Longridge, Ribble Valley, Lancashire. PR3 3WD

The Hepworth Band - Championship Brass & Voices for Christmas

Saturday 9 December • Thornhill Parish Church, Dewsbury WF12 0JZ

Littleport Brass Band

December 3 • Littleport Band have vacancies for 2nd Horn, BBb Bass & cornet (pos negotiable) We are a Cambridgeshire 3rd section band who are ambitious but friendly, working with our talented MD Ian Johnson. We rehearse on Wednesday evenings in our own band room.

Middleton Youth Band

December 2 • Calling all young brass players! We have exciting opportunities for bass, euphonium, and tenor horn players aged 7 and up in our friendly and fun youth band.. We have plenty of room for players of all instruments, too. Try us out!.

Lindley Band

December 2 • SECOND EUPHONIUM required to complete our friendly team under our experienced MD Alan Widdop. We enjoy a mix of concerts and contests.. Our bandroom is just 1mile from M62 Jcn 24 and we rehearse Monday and Wednesday evenings 8 to 9.45pm..

Phillip Lawrence

Composer, conductor, teacher


 © 2023 4barsrest.com Ltd