*
banner

A dangerous and ill thought through proposal

Councils in Scotland are reportedly looking at making cuts that could directly affect the teaching of music and free music tuition in schools.

Money
  The cuts are being reported in a number of council budgets in Scotland

It has been reported by both 'The Scotsman' newspaper and the 'Times Educational Supplement' that Midlothian Council in Scotland has put forward plans to cut free instrumental teaching.

It has been stated that the decision will affect pupils who are not taking Scottish Qualifications Authority exams such as Highers of National 5s in music as part of a plan that would see overall education budget savings of £520,000.

If agreed by the full council, it has been reported that it would save the council £444,000 a year with 8.8 full time job equivalents withdrawn.

Protesters

Protesters believe that the decision would be contrary to a Scottish Government pledge to make music lessons free for all.

One of those is Alastair Orr, an instrumental music instructor with over 30 years of experience.

He has long campaigned for the protection of instrumental music and vocal tuition in schools. He described Midlothian Council's proposal as "a dangerous and ill-thought-through proposal".

He added: "If implemented, this would see only those pupils sitting [Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA)] music examinations receiving music tuition.

Running the music service this way — just for those sitting SQA exams — would choke off those receiving tuition in primary schools and in early secondary. Effectively, over time, allowing the service to die."

Within funding

In its proposal, Midlothian Council stated: "As a result of a Scottish government and [local authorities' body] Cosla agreement, no charging fees for children learning a musical instrument was introduced academic session 2021-22.

The proposal is to operate an instrumental music service within the funding provided by the Scottish government; this will equate to £206,000."

However, protesters such as Mr Orr feel that this funding — which amounts to £8 million for the current academic year — was meant to cover fees charged to families, not the whole cost of delivering the music service.

They are now said to be beginning to mobilise to oppose the plans which could result in the most extreme proposals being revised or cancelled. It was stated that "if councils are flying a kite, it needs to be metaphorically shot down".

Running the music service this way — just for those sitting SQA exams — would choke off those receiving tuition in primary schools and in early secondary. Effectively, over time, allowing the service to dieAlastair Orr

Council cuts

The cuts being considered by Midlothian follow the news that Glasgow City Council is reportedly also looking at saving proposals that could result in teaching jobs in saving £51 million.

Scotland's First minister Nicola Sturgeon has been asked about some of the cuts being considered by councils and stated that this was, "the time of year when we hear lots of reports about the savings options that different councils are considering"and added that, "very often, those proposals do not proceed."

Unthinkable

Meanwhile the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland (ADES) said there was, "no doubt that the scale of financial savings is unprecedented and follows year-on-year cuts over the last ten-year period.

Councils are now considering what was previously unthinkable, such as shortening the school week or reducing teacher numbers."

School Leaders Scotland general secretary Jim Thewliss also said, "some of the things we are starting to hear discussed now have never been discussed before".

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Childs

2025 RNCM International Brass Band Festival: Interview with Prof Nicholas Childs

January 22 • We find out more about the programme of music from this world and beyond to be featured on Saturday evening at the RNCM from the Queensbury band and Galactico soloists.


mARZELLA

2025 RNCM International Brass Band Festival: Interview with Katrina Marzella-Wheeler

January 21 • We catch up with the Scottish conductor to find out more about the programme to be performed by the RNCM Brass Band on the weekend in Manchester.


Kaitlin

CBSO boosted by Wild trumpet addition

January 21 • The brass section of another leading British orchestra is boosted by the arrival of a brass band player as Kaitlin Wild joins the trumpet section of the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra.


Blackpool

North West Area line-ups announced

January 21 • The list of bands and judges have been confirmed for the North West Regional Championships in Blackpool in February.


The Hepworth Band - Hepworth Band New Year Celebration Concert

Sunday 26 January • Christ Church, New Mill, Holmfirth HD97ER


Dobcross Silver Band - Hammonds Band

Sunday 26 January • c/o Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross Saddleworth OL3 5AD


Contest: Norwegian National Brass Band Championships

Friday 7 February • Grieghallen, Bergen, N-5015. N-5015


Contest: Norwegian National Brass Band Championships

Saturday 8 February • Grieghallen, Bergen, N-5015 N-5015


Haverhill Silver Band - Concert in Clare Church

Saturday 8 February • St Peter and St Paul Church, Clare, Suffolk CO10 8NY


HYDE BAND

January 22 • WE HAVE PLAYER VACANCIES (POSITIONS NEGOTIABLE) Come and join our friendly First Section Band based in the New forest, and enjoy working with our Musical Director: Ben Halstead on a varied programme of concerts and contest.


Reading Spring Gardens Brass Band

January 22 • Reading Band (current joint 1st place in the L&SC 4th section grading tables and 2024 4th section National Finalists) needs BASSES! Rehearsals in Woodley (RG5) on Thursday evenings with our new MD Stephen Bucknell.


The Harrogate Band

January 22 • The Harrogate Band are looking for a front row cornet player to join them at the 1st Section North of England area contest and beyond! With a great bandroom, a wide range of engagments and a committed team, we'd love to see you.


David W. Ashworth

RSCM, ABBA Exec Member, NABBC PRO.
Conductor, Band Trainer and Adjudicator


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd