Report & Result: 2021 Besson Scottish Open

A Gallery full of outstanding musical portraits sees Whitburn claim the Scottish Open title for a seventh successive year.

Perth Concert Hall
  Whitburn claimed the Scottish Open title for a ninth time

Whitburn's stranglehold on the Besson Scottish Open Championship continued in Perth as they secured their seventh consecutive victory at the event in commanding fashion.

Led by Prof Nicholas Childs, and just a stone's throw from the city's own museum and art gallery, they produced a performance of Howard Snell's acutely observed appreciation of portraiture in a manner that brokered no argument.

Class apart

They were a class apart; the three-point winning margin fully justified after a 'Gallery' rendition that was described by adjudicators Steven Mead and Paul Holland as "outstanding" and containing "exceptional" contributions.

On a work demanding of an informed appreciation of both its technical and aesthetic challenges, it was high quality playing; stylistically varied and characterised, tonally balanced and executed with defined precision.

Each 'portrait' was given time and space in its examination by the MD; from the feral bustle of the Barras market to the slippery wit of the Skating Reverend, the sombre tread of the 'March back to Camp' and the tenderest evocation of an old couple's love.

The jagged dayglo colours of Matisse 'cut-outs' gave way to the noblest of majestic vistas of Ben Lomond to close.

Tour guide

Prof Childs was like a tour guide leading a gallery lecture; one enhanced by notable contributions especially from the Best Soloist award winner Scott Forest on soprano, who opened the door to the Whitburn musical viewing with a sweet confidence that was immediately built on by the ensemble.

They will now have to find room on a gallery wall of their own to display yet another framed winner's banner, whilst their bandhall display case of contesting silverware will house the impressive Scottish Open trophy for a ninth time.

Speaking to 4BR, the winning MD (who also claimed success here for a seventh time) said: "It's always good to come up and work with a band with such an appetite to keep improving and keep challenging themselves. The confidence they have in each other as players is something special and so is that desire to keep winning."

Cross border battle

Behind Whitburn came a keen, if distant cross border battle for the podium places, with Paul Holland giving a clear synopsis of what he and Steven Mead were comparing in the box in reaching their eventual decision.

They certainly found plenty of well drilled substance to admire in a rejuvenated Reg Vardy who claimed the runner-up spot.

Their solidly executed rendition of Kenneth Downie's 'St Magnus' under MD Steve Malcolm was also aided by the outstanding euphonium contribution of Andrew Hedley, who deservedly won the 'Best Euphonium' accolade.

There was also delight for another band making welcome progress back to top section competitiveness, as Kirkintilloch under David Roberts ended third with an adroitly considered appreciation of Simon Dobson's '…and when the river told…'

Both bands will have been boosted in contesting confidence as they look ahead to the challenges of 2022.

Another will be Easington Colliery who continued their rich run of recent form to end in fourth thanks to a vibrant 'St Magnus' under Ray Farr.

There will be disappointment, but few complaints however for fans of Scottish champion, the cooperation band.

They were unable to rid themselves of the contesting rust of Covid-19 inactivity with an error strewn 'St Magnus' to eventually end fifth, whilst the final top-six place went to Bon-Accord Silver with an energetic portrayal of Kenneth Downie's work.


Understandably the vast majority of the competitors sought to impress Paul Holland and Steven Mead with the familiar musical challenges posed by 'St Magnus' (7 bands) and 'Gallery' (5 bands).

However, as Kirkintilloch certainly displayed, Simon Dobson's evocation of the rich history of Perth, would perhaps would have suited a number better. They certainly showed it to be a work well worth reconsideration and revival.

And whilst it was no surprise that the demanding tessitura and complex intricacies of the former European set work 'Muckle Flugga' failed to find a willing volunteer, the lack of a performance of Peter Meechan's 'Macbeth' perhaps showed that some ambitions on 'St Magnus' and 'Gallery' were more than a little misplaced.

Despite the obvious inconsistencies brought by recent contesting inactivity and some over ambition, there was still a great deal to enjoy with the remaining performances from the top ten finishers of Unison Kinneil ('Gallery'), Dalmellington ('St Magnus'), Elland Silver ('St Magnus') and East London Brass ('Gallery').

However, at the bottom end it was perhaps a little more hard work for Fishburn, Kirkintilloch Kelvin (both 'St Magnus'), and Bo'ness & Carriden ('Gallery').

Excellent organisation

SBBA's excellently organised event certainly offered bands an ideal opportunity to take a significant step back to regular top flight contesting. Aided by the understanding approach to Covid-19 and registration issues (players were required by Perth Concert Hall protocols to sit 1 meter apart), it saw a number of well known 'deps' liberally sprinkled around the ranks.

It was also hoped that the 2022 event will see the return of the two absentee bands who were unfortunately forced to withdraw — Rainford with Covid-19 issues and the luckless 1st Old Boys from Northern Ireland who fell foul of the poor weather and the cancellation of their ferry.

Iwan Fox

On a work demanding of an informed appreciation of both its technical and aesthetic challenges, it was high quality playing; stylistically varied and characterised, tonally balanced and executed with defined precision4BR


Adjudicators: Paul Holland; Steven Mead
Own choice selection: '...and when the river told...' (Dobson); 'Gallery' (Snell); Macbeth (Meechan); 'Muckle Flugga' (Boyle); 'St Magnus' (Downie)

1. Whitburn (Prof Nicholas Childs) — 195
2. Reg Vardy (Steve Malcolm) — 192
3. Kirkintilloch Band (David Roberts) — 190
4. Easington Colliery (Ray Farr) — 189
5. the cooperation band (Mike Fowles) — 188
6. Bon-Accord Silver (Adam Cooke) — 187
7. Unison Kinneil (Raymond Tennant) — 186
8. Dalmellington (Gary Williams) — 185
9. Elland Silver (Daniel Brooks) — 184
10. East London Brass (Jayne Murrill) — 183
11. Fishburn (Lewis Wilkinson) — 182
12. Kirkintilloch Kelvin (David Thornton) — 181
13. Bo'ness & Carriden (Nigel Boddice MBE) — 180

Withdrew: Rainford; 1st Old Boys

4BR Best Soloist: Scott Forest (soprano) — Whitburn
Besson Best Euphonium: Andrew Hedley (Reg Vardy)

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    

Rex Richardson

All that jazz and more...

May 21 • Two ensembles from Brass Band of Battle Creek made sure the local population was left in no doubt who was in town this weekend...


French Open maintains attraction

May 21 • The 26th French Open Championships will take place in the wonderful Loire Valley town of Amboise next month.


Sounds of Summer brass returns to Leeds

May 21 • The wonderful sounds of brass bands playing in public bandstands will be heard again in Leeds this year.


Double attraction at Oxford Contest

May 20 • There is something for both bands and composers to aim for at the Oxfordshire & District Brass Band Association Entertainment Contest later this year.

Perth Festival of the Arts - The Brewin Dolphin Gala Opening Concert

Thursday 19 May • Perth Concert Hall, Mill Street, Perth PH1 5HZ

Perth Festival of the Arts - Reverie: The Life and Loves of Claude Debussy

Friday 20 May • Perth Theatre, Mill Street, Perth PH1 5HZ

Perth Festival of the Arts - Perthshire Brass at Perth Festival of the Arts

Saturday 21 May • St Paul's Church Plaza, St Paul's Square PH1 5PA

Black Dyke Band - 2nd Rossendale Scouts, Rossendale Male Voice Choir

Saturday 21 May • The Bridgewater Hall, Lower Mosley St, M2 3WS

Lofthouse 2000 Brass Band - Brass for YAS Charity Concert

Saturday 21 May • St Austin's Theatre, Wakefield, Wentworth Terrace. Wakefield, West Yorkshire WF1 3QN United Kingdom WF1 3QN

Otley Brass Association

May 22 • Musical Director - Otley Brass Band. . Required:. Our enthusiastic, unregistered band is looking for a new MUSICAL DIRECTOR. Located in Otley to the North West of Leeds we rehearse on Tuesday Evenings from 1930-2145 at the Otley Courthouse

Avonbank (Evesham) Brass Band

May 21 • We're a happy second section band in Worcestershire and we'd love you to join us on our front row or, if you prefer, on the back. We have a full summer and autumn programme planned and want to welcome you to our ranks! Please get in touch!

Stretford Band

May 20 • Tenor horn required. We are a local, friendly band with a varied concert programme in the following months. If you are returning to banding or looking for a change please come along and meet the band.

Michael Bennett

BSc, RNCM (Perf)
Performer, Composer, Arranger, Teacher


 © 2022 4barsrest.com Ltd