*
banner

Symphonic variants in Covid-19 dispute in USA

A Covid-19 vaccination dispute has arisen in the USA between a symphony orchestra and a player that could cross to the UK and beyond.

Covid
  The player said her religious beliefs preventing her from getting the vaccine

In an interesting Covid-19 development in the USA, it has been reported that a symphony orchestra has barred an unvaccinated musician from performing with them.

The Wilmington Symphony Orchestra is based in southeastern North Carolina and was due to start its 50th anniversary concert celebrations this Autumn.

Formed in 1971, according to its website it provides, "symphonic music at the highest degree of excellence through performance opportunities for regional musicians and educational programs for our community's youth."

Ebroiled

However, it has become embroiled in a highly publicised dispute with clarinet player Martha Dippold after she was allegedly told she cannot play with the orchestra until she gets a COVID-19 vaccination.

It is understood that performers with the orchestra are not full-time employees but freelance players who receive a fee for their services.

The story is being closely monitored by both professional and semi-professional musical ensembles in the UK and Europe due to its possible legal implications.

Immunity

According to the online Wilmington Star News website, it was reported that the musician who has performed with the orchestra for around five years, felt the decision was "very disappointing".

The musician stated that she had "almost died"from Covid-19 last December and that she now believed that it had given her a "robust"immunity from the virus.

It was reported that the orchestra's Executive Director Liz Scanlon had previously sent a letter to its performers saying they needed to be vaccinated in order to perform with them.

However it did note that players could request a medical or religious exemption, but that there was no guarantee it would be granted.

Beliefs

However, Martha Dippold was reported as stating that her religious beliefs also prevented her from getting the vaccine.

There has been a great deal of debate surrounding Covid-19 vaccination in the USA in various religious communities, something which the player noted in respect to vaccine testing in her interview.

The musician stated that she had "almost died" from Covid-19 last December and that she now believed that it had given her a "robust" immunity from the virus4BR

Carefully reviewed

In a written statement, WSO Executive Director Liz Scanlon stated: "…the WSO is committed to providing a safe, inclusive, and supportive experience for all, including musicians, staff, and concert-goers.

In furtherance of such commitment and after careful consideration, we have implemented a mandatory vaccination policy for all musicians or performers.

Any requests for exemptions to such policy, be it for medical or religious reasons, have been and will continue to be carefully reviewed and evaluated, weighing our desire for safety, the nature of the particular request, and the scientific evidence or facts pertinent to such requests."

No grudge

The news report by journalist John Staton concluded with Martha Dippold stating that she felt "targeted over her refusal to take the vaccine", although as she "did not hold any grudges"she hoped one day to play with the orchestra again.

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Rooms for groups

Hotel bookings ready to be sorted for Cheltenham and London

March 16 • Another raft of regional winners and qualifiers can get in touch with the hotel accommodation specialists rooms4groups this morning to sort out a welcome headache...


wELSH aREA

Results: 2025 Welsh Regional Championships

March 15 • Tredegar leads the way as Welsh Champion with section wins for Parc & Dare, Deiniolen Silver, City of Wrexham and Holywell in Swansea


Stevenage

Results: 2025 London & Southern Counties Area Championships

March 15 • East London Brass claims the Championship honours in Stevenage with Kidlington Concert Brass, Jersey Premier, Betteshanger and Cobham taking the section titles.


cIVIC cENTRE

Result: 2025 Midlands Second Section Area Championship

March 15 • Carlton Brass claims the Second Section honours in Bedworth


Regent Hall Concerts - The Band of the RAF Regiment

Friday 21 March • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Berkeley Brass

Friday 21 March • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Contest: North of England Regional Championships

Saturday 22 March • 1 Millennium Place, Durham DH1 1WA


Regent Hall Concerts - Household Troops Band of the Salvation Army

Saturday 22 March • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Contest: North of England Regional Championships

Sunday 23 March • 1 Millennium Place, Durham DH1 1WA


Chinnor Silver

March 17 • What a day, 2nd place in our regional contest, qualification for the National Finals and promotion to the 1st Section. However we need basses( Bb or Eb) and percussionists to join us on our exciting journey. Rehearsals are Wednesday evenings in Chinnor.


Enderby Band

March 16 • Musical Director required. . Enderby Band are a championship section band based in the village of Enderby in Leicestershire. . . Rehearsals are Tuesday and Friday evenings 8pm until 10pm. . . Resident or professional sought depending on experience.


Enderby Band

March 16 • Bass trombone and Bb Bass required.. . Enderby Band are a championship section band based in the village of Enderby in Leicestershire.. . Rehearsals are Tuesday and Friday evenings 8pm to 10pm at the Enderby Village Institute.


Chris King

MBA, BMus(Hons), LRSM, AoBBA
Conductor, Arranger, Adjudicator, Compere, Band Trainer


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd