*
banner

This is not the Civil Service — we're creating art...

Row over Phantom of the Opera musician job losses set to continue as producer reportedly says creating art doesn't ensure ad infinitum job security.

Phantom
  The shows have grossed over $6 billion dollars since 1986

Theatre impresario Cameron Mackintosh has reportedly told the Daily Telegraph newspaper in an interview that although he is "sorry"some musicians will loss their jobs when the West End production of 'Phantom of the Opera' returns in July, he also believes producers should not hold jobs for actors and musicians "ad infinitum".

It has been reported that that the show will use a reduced orchestration of 14 musicians when it resumes performances — an almost 50 percent reduction in the 27-member pit orchestra used prior its temporary closure due to Covid-19.

Just as thrilling

And whilst following the news a joint statement from Cameron Mackintosh Ltd and the Really Useful Group it was revealed that the new West End production of Phantom would be "using the acclaimed orchestration for 14 musicians that was created for the international productions of the show", and that "...the orchestrations are just as thrilling and rich as the original but would not have been possible with the technology available in 1986", the announcement was met with widespread criticism.

That appears to be set to continue after it was reported by Daily Telegraph Theatre Critic Dominic Cavendish that Cameron Mackintosh said that he had endured "…a terrible year trying to keep on as many people as I can, but our job is to try to put a show on that can run and be brilliant."

Not the Civil Service

However, in defending the decision, he reportedly added: "Am I sorry? I'm sorry they're upset, but I do find it odd why musicians would want to keep doing the same thing year after year.

I believe we should not be holding jobs for actors or musicians ad infinitum. This is not the Civil Service, we're creating art."

When asked if he and Andrew Lloyd Weber were in danger of ruining what made Phantom of the Opera such as success in combining a "thrilling sound matching the palatial visual granduer", it was reported that he had "spent 50 years delivering the highest quality musicals this country has seen and I'm not about to stop now."

I believe we should not be holding jobs for actors or musicians ad infinitum. This is not the Civil Service, we're creating artCameron Mackintosh

Excellent replication

Andrew Lloyd Weber meanwhile reportedly conceded that some for the music will now be played on a keyboard, although he added: "Today's technology enables excellent replication of sounds, especially woodwind and brass".

The show is estimated to have made over $6 billion since it was first launched in 1986 with the London production at the 1,200 seat Her Majesty's Theatre, the second longest running West End show.

It celebrated its 10,000th performance in 2010.

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Full

Youth Champs packed full following record registrations

October 16 • The 2027 National Youth Championships of Great Britain are full to the brim after unprecedented response from those wanting to take part.


Santa

Wright & Round: Santa Claus is Coming to Town (Michael Buble arr. Chris Wormald)

October 16 • You can't beat a little bit of Buble for Christmas...


ABRSM

ABRSM fined over serious shortcomings

October 16 • The Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music has been fined £150,000 by Ofqual over serious shortcomings in its arrangements for retaining and managing assessment evidence.


Tredegar

Tredegar provide penultimate Orbital launch

October 16 • The fourth commissioning premiere of Richard Blackford's major composition has been given by Tredegar in West Sussex.


Regent Hall Concerts - Queentet

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Funny Bones Symphonic Brass

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Fulham Brass Band

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Dobcross Silver Band -

Friday 16 October • Playhouse 2 . 2 Newtown street. Shaw. Oldham OL2 8NX


The Egham Band - The Egham Band Plays Classic Rock

Friday 16 October • St John's Church Egham, Manor Farm Lane, Egham tw20 9HR


Crewe Brass

October 16 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Front Row Cornet player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

October 16 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Eb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

October 16 • Crewe Brass are looking for a BBb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Ian Porthouse


Cornet soloist, clinician, conductor and adjudicator


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd