*
banner

Legal challenge to be mounted against discretionary charges in Scotland

A crowdfunding appeal is top be launched to challenge the legality of charging for discretionary music services in Scotland.

Money
  There are different approaches and different levels of charges for the services in the Scottish local authorities.

Despite the Scottish Parliament's Education & Skills Committee publishing a recent report that strongly recommended its support for free music tuition in local authorities, the battle to stop the charges being imposed is still being fought.

Crowdfunding

The latest move is once again being spearheaded by Ralph Riddiough, a partner at Ayr based firm Kilpatrick & Walker who also plays trombone with the Dalmellington Band.

He is seeking secure crowdfunding to mount a legal challenge against the implementation of charges for what is seen as a discretionary service in the majority of Scotland's 32 local authorities.

Ralph believes that it is incorrect to legally class instrumental tuition as discretionary and not a core part of the education curriculum. He feels that the subsequent charges have been applied in contravention of the 1980 Education Scotland Act.

Discretionary

In an on-line article published in 'The Herald' newspaper Ralph is quoted as saying: "The fees turn on the word 'discretionary'. Everyone seems to think that education is only education if local authorities deliver it using the money sent to them by the Scottish Government.

Discretionary really means that local authorities deliver the tuition and they fund it from their own funds. The money used to pay for tutors and the cost of repairing instruments comes from local authorities' own coffers and that's why the word discretionary has come about. That seems to be fair game for fees."

The challenge will be partly based on the recent findings and recommendations of the Education & Skills Committee report entitled; 'A note of concern: The future of instrumental music tuition in schools'.

The report was published by a 11 member cross-party committee who took evidence from a variety of sources; including parents, teachers, students, musicians and a number of different educational sources and interested parties.

The report stated that there was "a lack of clarity" whether charging for instrumental tuition in senior secondary education was legitimate4BR

Lack of clarity

The report stated that there was "a lack of clarity" whether charging for instrumental tuition in senior secondary education was legitimate.

It also recommended that that the Scottish Government clarified the "legal basis for such charges" in line with its view that it believed that "instrumental music tutors should be considered to be part of core education provision."

Ralph plans to launch his fundraising campaign on crowdfunding site CrowdJustice in the coming weeks, with the intention of taking one local authority to court to ask a judge to clarify the position.

"Asking a court to decide what is and what is not education if it isn't delivered in a classroom of 30 kids carries risk, I know,"he said. "But I think the case is strong."

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


bbca hARPER

Harper guest spotlight with BBCA

November 19 • The Cory MD will be the guest of the Brass Band Conductors' Association on their next Zoom webinar on Tuesday 24th November.


BrookWright

BrookWright Music: Christmas for Two

November 19 • Bring the joy of the season to life with a unique collection of 70 well-loved Christmas carols and songs, expertly arranged by William Himes — and just for two players.


Garlick topping for Fairey's festive visit to Dobcross

November 19 • A great day of workshops, family fun and interaction is in store when KNDS Fairey head to Dobcross next month.


Brain

Musical memories are more shared than we may have originally thought

November 19 • New research finds that the power of music in shaping our memories is an effective way of bringing people together through similar shared experiences.


Regent Hall Concerts - Band of the RAF Regiment Brass Ensemble

Friday 20 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Bilton Silver Rugby Band - Bilton Silver President's Concert

Friday 27 November • St George's Church, St Johns Avenue, Rugby CV22 5HR


West Yorkshire Police Band - Mid Yorkshire Breast Cancer Support

Saturday 28 November • Cluntergate Centre, Horbury WF4 5DA


Newstead Brass - The Snowman - Live

Saturday 5 December • Forest Town Arena. Clipstone Road West, Forest Town. Mansfield NG19 0EE


Bilton Silver Rugby Band - Christmas Magic and More

Sunday 13 December • Rugby Theatre, Henry Street, Rugby, Warwickshire CV21 2QA


Brunel Brass Organisation

November 20 • Brunel Brass is looking for a Eb or Bb BASS to complete the band. Challenging for promotion to the Championship Section in 2027 and achieving our highest ever result at the British Open Senior Trophy in 2026, it's an exciting time to join the band!


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Front Row Cornet player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Eb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


John Durrant

MA LLCM TD CertEd (Dist)
Conductor, Band Trainer, Composer, Trumpet and Cornet Soloist, Arranger, Adjudicator


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd