*
banner

A timely contest reminder...

Passions will run high on the Whit Friday circuit this weekend, but then again, that's nothing new — although hopefully it won't be anything like this contest from 1896...

Police
  Not often the police are called to sort out a musical dispute — in the middle of a contest.

Although there is nothing new about disgruntled players moaning about results in the bar after a competition has finished, modern-day bad banding behaviour can't match events of over 100 years ago — especially given that it took place during the contest itself.

The report comes from the South Wales Daily News of April 1896, concerning a Bank Holiday contest held in Newport, where the test-piece seemed rather apt….

Afterwards, in the presence of a very small gathering, the Fochriw Band played the test piece in capital style, and, there being no other competitors, as their players had fallen foul of the local constabulary, carried off the prize4BR

The correspondent wrote:

"One of the programmes of amusement provided for the holiday-keepers at Newport on Bank Holiday Monday had a remarkable denouement.

This was a brass band contest in connection with an eisteddfod… or to be strictly accurate, was arranged to take place, for the contest proved the reverse of musical. The test piece was a selection from 'Lucrezia Borgia' and six bands entered for the £20 prize.

Amongst these was the Fochriw brass band, the others being two bands from Blaenavon, one from Abertillery, another from Pontypridd, and the sixth from Mid-Rhondda.

The Fochriw band, it appears, won a prize last year at a prominent eisteddfod, and this fact, it was argued, placed it in a higher level and rendered unfair its competition on the same terms with the other bands, which partook much more of the amateur element.

This feeling displayed itself unpleasantly.

When the Fochriw band attempted to play they were met by discordant notes from the instruments of some of the members of the other bands, who crowded in behind the public at the bottom of the hall. Such unmannerly conduct gave rise to considerable uproar, and ultimately the police were called in.

The hall had to be cleared of the disturbers, and during this interval a number of the audience left.

Afterwards, in the presence of a very small gathering, the Fochriw Band played the test piece in capital style, and, there being no other competitors, as their players had fallen foul of the local constabulary, carried off the prize."

Just a little something to bear in mind for the various Whit Friday shindigs this weekend…

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


RWCMD

Royal Welsh College defends claims that culture hasn't changed

October 18 • The Royal Welsh College of Music & Drama has refuted claims that its culture hasn't changed three years after it was found negligent in a case of alleged sexual assault.


McDonnell

McDonnell highlights risks of losing BBE gold standard BOPA

October 17 • Labour MP John McDonnell has written of the need for the Department of Education to reconsider its decision to end Brass Bands England BOPA provision in April next year.


nATIONAL yOUTH cHAMPS

New opportunities and roles to play at Youth Championships

October 17 • From volunteer helpers to photographers, presenters and judges — Brass Bands England puts the call to be part of the 2027 National Youth Championships of Great Britain.


Espen Westbye

Westbye returns to take up residency in Stavanger

October 17 • Espen Westbye will join forces with David Morton at Stavanger as he returns as Resident Conductor ahead of Siddis challenge.


Regent Hall Concerts - Queentet

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Funny Bones Symphonic Brass

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Regent Hall Concerts - Fulham Brass Band

Friday 16 October • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Dobcross Silver Band -

Friday 16 October • Playhouse 2 . 2 Newtown street. Shaw. Oldham OL2 8NX


The Egham Band - The Egham Band Plays Classic Rock

Friday 16 October • St John's Church Egham, Manor Farm Lane, Egham tw20 9HR


Kibworth Band

October 19 • Kibworth Band (First Section - South Leicestershire) seeking percussionist to join our friendly, ambitious team. Any seat negotiable. We rehearse Monday and Thursday evenings in our purpose built band room.


Kibworth Band

October 19 • Kibworth Band (First Section - South Leicestershire) seeking a BBb Bass player to join our friendly, ambitious team. Any seat negotiable. We rehearse Monday and Thursday evenings in our purpose built band room.


Kibworth Band

October 19 • Kibworth Band (First Section - South Leicestershire) seeking a euphonium player to join our friendly, ambitious team. Any seat negotiable. We rehearse Monday and Thursday evenings in our purpose built band room.


James McLeod

BMus (hons)
Euphonium Soloist, Teacher and Conductor


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd