Report & Results: 2017 Senior Cup

Delight for Filton Concert as they claim the Senior Trophy honours and head to the Grand Shield alongside the promoted trio of Friary Guildford, East Yorkshire Motor Sevices and City of Cardiff (Melingriffith)

  Filton Concert Brass celebrates victory at the Senior Cup

Filton Concert Brass, an organisation with an innovative 21st century approach to overcoming the historic 20th century challenges of contesting, produced a performance full of traditional high quality musical virtues to claim the Senior Cup.

In keeping with their ethos though, their evocative rendition of 'Fragile Oasis' still gave the judges 'something extra' under MD Tom Davoren, in what was an entertaining battle in claiming a second successive victory at the Spring Festival, following last year's Senior Trophy success.

Written for you

It certainly made the right impression on the two men in the box — with Paul Holland describing it in his written remarks as; '…a terrific performance, expertly directed'.

Meanwhile, John Doyle, (who played in major role in getting the work commissioned from composer Peter Meechan for Leyland Band in 2013), went even further: 'I feel this piece was written for you not Leyland!! Thank you so much for an outstanding and musical show. I have goosebumps.'

After qualifying for their first Albert Hall National Finals appearance earlier this year at Torquay, Filton is now just one step away from the British Open — a remarkable achievement for a band that was only formed in 1976 and has employed a very specific approach to meeting the modern day challenges faced by players who lead busy careers, but who still wish to play at the highest level.


"I don't think there is a Championship level band quite like us,"Tom Davoren admitted. "But it's an approach that has served us well for many years. It's one that appreciates individual player's needs without losing sight of what we all want to collectively achieve.

That flexibility of targeting specific objectives works for us. We had two this year — London and the Senior Cup, and it's paid off. The players deserve so much credit. We enjoy our brand of banding and I think there is much, much more to come."

Ambitious trio

Joining Filton in the Grand Shield in 2018 will be a trio of equally ambitious rivals — led by Friary Guildford, another well run band that continues to make a significant mark at Championship level. The London & Southern Counties Regional champion once again delivered in confident style on a major contest stage under Chris King, as they made an immediate return following last year's relegation.

Meanwhile, East Yorkshire Motor Services continued their good form under MD Stig Maersk, as unlike counterparts Reg Vardy in the Grand Shield, they headed back to the North of England delighted by their third placed finish. And on what was a disappointing day overall for Welsh banding, there was a fine result to celebrate for City of Cardiff (Melingriffith), as they secured the final promotion slot under Nigel Seaman.

Just missing out (with Paul Holland telling the audience that 'the top five' really brought out the energy, pulse and reflective lyricism required in what was a demanding test) came a fine account from Cornish contenders St Dennis, with the final top-six slot going to Ratby Co-operative.

Adjudicator praise

Speaking to 4BR, both judge's were full of praise for the efforts of the 20 competitors, with Paul particularly impressed by what he said was 'some really outstanding euphonium playing' as well as the general standard of all the solo contributions — none more so than Foden's Gary Curtin who shone as the 'Best Instrumentalist' guest player with Co-operative Funeralcare (North West).

However, there were others areas that also caught their ears in the box. "We enjoyed a great day,"Paul said before adding. "All the bands offered us something, but it was a straightforward decision. We felt a bit sorry for the band in fifth — it was very, very close to making it through.

The winners certainly gave us something extra and the top five were very good. We looked for balance, an accurate rhythmic pulse, colourful energy and the reflective lyricism."

John added: "The best gave us that, although sometimes the basses did overcook things and the faster sections were not always rhythmically accurate. We also felt there had been a bit of re-writing, especially in the solo cornet parts. I know they were hard, but it was a little bit blatant at times — as was some of the percussion playing. Some of it, as Paul said, was a little over the top."


With East Yorkshire Services providing the duo with an early marker of confidence and detail, it wasn't until after the mid-point break that they were topped on a piece that highlighted the need for a detailed appreciation of balance, texture and colour to go with its more obvious technical flourishes.

Filton certainly produced that with a performance that stuck in the mind: Tom Davoren's vibrant take; with a bold rhythmic structure underpinning the foundation on which a rich ensemble balance of wide dynamic range and top class soloists, from tuba to soprano shone, brought the score to life.

Behind them came Friary Guildford, with a mature account, which although not technically perfect had an authentic stamp of quality running through it from start to finish, whilst City of Cardiff (Melingriffith) showed fine dynamic control in a rendition that resonated in the box with its considered approach to pip St Dennis.

The Cornish band may have made the long trip home a little disappointed at missing out, but their emerging maturity should serve them well for the rest of this season and beyond under their talented MD.

Midfield batch

Ratby Co-operative's top-six finish was gained in no small part to Howard Evans' sensible approach as they headed home a batch of midfield finishers that showcased both their strengths and weaknesses. Each — from Goodwick in seventh to Kingdom Brass in thirteenth emerged from a stern test with merit, whilst others such as Oldham (Lees) will feel a little unlucky that their colourful account didn't quite resonate in the box as much as it did in the hall.

Behind them came those that found significantly more problems with 'Fragile Oasis' — although as the judge's pointed out, each brought something of note from the score. However, dropping through the relegation trap-door was Fishburn, Marsden Silver, Derwent Brass and Redbridge.

Fragile metaphor

With so many bands at the Spring Festival relying on 'help', 'Fragile Oasis' proved to be something of a musical metaphor for the 'fragile' state of many competitors. Less than 12 hours before the first contest was due to start, last minute 'signings' were still being processed by the hard working British Open registrar Colin Johnson.

Perhaps then, many could do with finding out how and why Filton has managed so successfully to overcome potential contest troubles that is inventive, flexible and ultimately successful. They are certainly an enlightening contesting band in all sorts of ways.

targeting specific objectives works for us. We had two this year — London and the Senior Cup, and it's paid off. The players deserve so much credit. We enjoy our brand of banding and I think there is much, much more to comeTom Davoren


Senior Cup:

Pavilion Theatre
Test Piece: Fragile Oasis (Dr Peter Meechan)
Adjudicators: John Doyle & Paul Holland

1. Filton Concert Brass (Tom Davoren)*
2. Friary Guildford (Chris King)*
3. East Yorkshire Motor Services (Stig Maersk)*
4. City of Cardiff (Melingriffith) (Nigel Seaman)*
5. St Dennis (Darren Hawken)
6. Ratby Co-operative (Howard Evans)
7. Goodwick Brass (Matthew Jenkins)
8. Co-operative Funeralcare (North West) (Jeff Sparkes)
9. Skelmanthorpe (Jim Davies)
10. Oldham (Lees) (John Collins)
11. Blackburn & Darwen (Neil Samuel)
12. Newtongrange Silver (Andrew Duncan)
13. Kingdom Brass (Paul Drury)
14. Staffordshire (Steven Walsh)
15. Jackfield (Elcock Reisen) (Simon Platford)
16. Yorkshire Imperial Urquhart Travel (Dr David Thornton)
17. Redbridge (Jeremy Wise)**
18. Derwent Brass (Keith Leonard)**
19. Marsden Silver (Alan Widdop)**
20. Fishburn (David Hirst)**

Best Instrumentalist: Gary Curtin (euphonium) — Co-operative Funeralcare (North West)

*Top four bands promoted to Grand Shield
**Bottom four bands relegated to Senior Trophy

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Christmas is coming...

November 29 • Soon it will be that time of the year again... and hopefully there will some festive cheer for brass bands across the globe.


Grimethorpe launches fund raising initiative

November 29 • One of the world's most famous bands spearheads Crowdfunder appeal to raise vital funds.


Helping others leads Mode for value

November 29 • Mode for...Publishing will be able to help others if you donate to get some great music on your festive stands.


Filton look for festive boost

November 29 • Filton Concert Brass launches its own festive shop to help raise funds.

The Marple Band - Marple Band Family Christmas Concert

Friday 18 December • Marple Conservative Club, church Lane, Marple, SK6 6AY

Black Dyke Band - Brighouse & Rastrick, Huddersfield Town Hall

Saturday 27 March • Corporation St, Huddersfield HD1 2TA

Contest: 100thSpring Festival

Saturday 8 May • 97 Church St, Blackpool, FY1 1HL

Contest: Whit Friday March Contests

Friday 28 May • Saddleworth & Tameside OL3

Contest: 168th British Open

Saturday 11 September • Symphony Hall, Broad Street, Birmingham. B1 2EA

Chadderton Band

November 17 • Chadderton Band is a non-contesting band playing at various events throughout the year. We are a friendly band looking for players of all ages and abilities on all sections + EUPH and percussion. Most welcome to come along and have a blow give us a try.

Crewe Brass

November 12 • Crewe Brass require an Eb or Bb Bass to complete the "engine room" line up. We are also seeking a Tuned Percussionist to complete our section.

Shipston Town Band

November 1 • We are currently looking to recruit a Bass Trombone BBb bass and EEb bass to bring the band up to strength ready for when things return to normal. We are graded section 3 in the Midlands taking part in a good range of concerts and contests

Michael Bennett

BSc, RNCM (Perf)
Performer, Composer, Arranger, Teacher


 © 2020 4barsrest.com Ltd