*
banner

Timing error sees review of Brass in Concert results

An error made by the organisers at the Brass in Concert Championship has led to an amendment of the official result — with Brass Band Schoonhoven promoted from sixth to fifth place.

The Sage
  From six to five — a timing error has meant Schoonhoven gains a place

The organisers of the 40th Brass in Concert Championship have announced an amendment to the final result of the 2016 event held at Sage Gateshead.

Brass Band Schoonhoven (above) was originally given a two-point penalty for exceeding the 23-minute time limit on musical performance.

However, it has since come to light that an error was made in the timing of their first two pieces, meaning that their overall programme was incorrectly registered as being 56 seconds longer than it should have been.

Timing error

Speaking on behalf of Brass in Concert, John Woods told 4BR: "We go to great lengths to make sure that the timing process at Brass in Concert is carried out as accurately as possible, but in this case the demarcation between Brass Band Schoonhoven's first two pieces wasn't entirely clear and, unfortunately, an incorrect time was recorded.

We were subsequently contacted by the band and asked to check our timings, which we did using both audio and video recordings."

Sixth to fifth

He added: "As a result of our findings the time penalty initially imposed has been retracted and Schoonhoven has been promoted to fifth place, with Flowers now being placed sixth.

We would like to apologise to the management and players of Flowers and Schoonhoven, as well as recognising the professional manner in which both bands have treated the matter. While it may appear small consolation to Flowers, our organising team was unanimous in agreeing that the band should keep the prize money as it was originally announced.

We have also agreed to review our timing rules and procedures prior to next year's event and will make any amendments known to competing bands as soon as this is complete."

Amended official result:

Adjudicators:


In order of marks:
Les Neish & Florent Didier (Music: Quality of Performance)
Mike Kilroy (Programme Content)
Duncan Stubbs & Derek Southcott (Entertainment)

Music/Music/Content/Entertainment = Total
Neish/Didier/Kilroy/Stubbs/Southcott = Total

1. Cory (Philip Harper): (1) 60 / (1) 60 / (1) 40 / (3) 18 / (1) 20: 198pts
2. Grimethorpe Colliery (Phillip McCann): (2) 57 / (3) 54 / (5) 32 / (1) 20 / (2) 19: 182pts
3. Brighouse & Rastrick (Leigh Baker): (3) 54 / (6) 45 / (4) 34 / (5) 16 / (3) 18: 167pts
4. Carlton Main Frickley Colliery (Ian McElligott): (4) 51 / (7) 42 / (2) 38 / (4) 17 / (4) 17: 165pts
5. Brass Band Schoonhoven (Ivan Meylemans): (10) 33 / (2) 57 / (3) 36 / (2) 19 / (10) 11: 156pts
6. Flowers (Paul Holland): (6) 45 / (5) 48 / (6) 30 / (6) 15 / (5) 16: 154pts
7. Stavanger (Allan Withington): (5) 48 / (4) 51 / (7) 28 / (9) 12 / (11) 10: 149pts
8. Virtuosi GUS (Adam Cooke): (8) 39 / (9) 36 / (8) 26 / (8) 13 / (7) 14: 128pts
9. Reg Vardy (Russell Gray): (9) 36 / (8) 39 / (10) 22 / (7) 14 / (8) 13: 124pts
10. Hammonds Saltaire (Morgan Griffiths): (7) 42 / (10) 33 / (11) 20 / (11) 10 / (6) 15: 120pts
11. Dublin Silver (Tim Jameson): (11) 30 / (11) 30 / (9) 24 / (10) 11 / (9) 12: 107pts

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Nicola Shaw

Inspirational Shaw shortlisted for Unsung Hero award

November 5 • The fantastic music education work of Adams artist Nicola Shaw has been recognised by her being shortlisted for a Music Mark award.


Childs

Childs returns to Japan for Roman spectacular

November 5 • Prof Nicholas Childs recently returned to Japan work alongside the iconic figure of Prof Emeritus, Takeo Yamamoto and the students at Senzoku Gakuen College.


Elgar Festival

RBC to host Elgar International Festival of Brass

November 5 • The Royal Birmingham Conservatoire will host the Elgar International Festival of Brass in 2026.


Frank Renton

An evening with Frank

November 5 • Frank Renton will be the guest on the latest Brass Band Conductors Association spotlight evening webcast.


Regent Hall Concerts - Royal Greenwich Brass Band

Friday 7 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Dobcross Silver Band - Remembrance Concert

Sunday 9 November • c/o Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross Saddleworth OL3 5AD


Delph Band - Remembrance Sunday Concert

Sunday 9 November • Delph Band Club. Lawton Square, . Delph, . Oldham OL3 5DT


Regent Hall Concerts - Five By 5 Trumpet Ensemble

Friday 14 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. WC1 2DJ W1C2DJ


Contest: 48th Brass in Concert

Saturday 15 November • The Gladhous International Centre for Music, St Mary's Square, Gateshead NE8 2JR


Wotton-under-Edge Silver Band

November 4 • We are a busy and very friendly 2nd section band with 5 current vacancies - FRONT ROW CORNET – BACK ROW CORNET- EUPHONIUM - Bb BASS - PERCUSSION. We rehearse on Tuesdays & Thursdays near our lovely home town, just a short drive from M5, J14.


Harlow Brass Band

November 4 • We have vacancies for CORNETS, TROMBONES, 2ND HORN AND PERCUSSION. We are a welcoming, non contesting band who organising their own Spring and Christmas concerts and enjoy playing at local events throughout the year.


Chinnor Silver

November 4 • Our COMMUNITY BANDS next rehearsal is on Monday 10th at 11am and held in our bandroom.. Blowing with us doesn't impact your own band and its free.. We welcome all regardless of ability . Tea and cakes an added bonus.


James Garlick

BMus (Hons), QTS
Conductor, Band Trainer, Adjudicator, Tutor


               

 © 2025 4barsrest.com Ltd