*
banner

Harper lambasts test piece musical thuggery and charlatanism

Cory MD Philip Harper has opened up a debate on what he sees as the watering down in the quality of major test pieces...

Philip Harper
 

After leading Cory to the European title in Lille, MD Philip Harper has taken the opportunity to air his personal opinion to try and open a debate over what he sees is a growing trend by bands and contest promoters towards the commissioning and use of works where 'artistic sophistication and creativity has been substituted for musical thuggery and charlatanism'.

It comes after Cory won the European title in Lille with performances of the critically acclaimed brace of 'Fraternity' by Thierry Deleruyelle and their own commission of 'Raveling, Unraveling' by Philip Sparke.

Strongly worded

In a strongly worded blog on the Cory website he states that of the twelve test pieces he has directed his band on at the major contests of the British Open, National Championship of Great Britain and European Championship, only five he considers to be 'of the required quality' — although he does not name those which are and which are not.

He also goes on to explain why he believes the situation has developed — and the mistake he believes major contest promoters make in asking composers to write 'can do anything' works 'without compromise'.

It's a fascinating read...

In a strongly worded blog on the Cory website he states that of the twelve test pieces he has directed his band on at the major contests, only five he considers to be 'of the required quality'4BR

Go to:

http://coryband.com/2015/cory-band-european-champions-2016-band-on-a-mission/

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


Scotland

Scottish banding battles for success

June 1 • A recent article in one of Scotland's leading newspapers has highlighted both the successes and challenges faced by its banding organisations.


Cross

Death of David Banwell

June 1 • The death has been announced of David Banwell, the widely respected former player, conductor and member of the 4BR team.


Whit Friday

Whitsuntide celebration on Radio 4

May 31 • The celebration of Whitsuntide in Saddleworth has been marked on Radio 4 — accompanied by brass band music


Saddleworth

Report & Results: 2026 Saddleworth & Oldham District Whit Friday

May 31 • The official results from each venue have now been announced with confirmation that Brighouse & Rastrick are crowned champions as Milnrow take local honours and Tewit Silver Youth take the youth prize.


The Hepworth Band - Brassband Burgermusik Luzern

Saturday 30 May • Dewsbury Minster, Vicarage Road, Dewsbury, West Yorkshire WF12 8DD


Dobcross Silver Band - Unite the Union Band

Sunday 31 May • c/o Dobcross Band Club. Platt Lane. Dobcross Saddleworth OL3 5AD


Regent Hall Concerts - Ithaca Brass

Tuesday 2 June • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Fulham Brass Band - Summer Concert

Friday 5 June • St Dionis Church, Parsons Green SW6 4UH


Yorkshire Imperial - Roger Webster & The Colne Valley Male Voice Choir

Saturday 6 June • St George's Hall, Bridge Street, Bradford BD1 1JT


East London Brass

June 1 • Solo Cornet : fresh off the back of our promotion to the Grand Shield, ELB are on the look out for a solo cornet player to complement our existing section. The band is ambitious and has an exciting second half of the year ahead.


Tintwistle Band

May 28 • Tintwistle Band are looking for front row cornet players to help complete our team. . We rehearse Monday and Thursday 8-10pm at our own bandroom on Old Road in Tintwistle, under the baton of MD Jim Henson, and perform a variety of concerts all year round.


Chinnor Silver

May 28 • Our COMMUNITY BAND meets again on Monday(1st) at 11am and we welcome players of all abilities to come along and join us in a relaxed and friendly rehearsal.. What is not to like = wont effect your no1 band ,its free and with coffee and cake


Jonathan Pippen


Conductor, Adjudicator, Trombone Soloist & Clinician


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd