*
banner

Scientists find that it's sight rather than sound that makes a judge's decision

According to a new study professional musicians only manage to pick the right competition winner a quarter of the time when they listen but don't see...

Adjudicators box
 

The findings of a study published by the PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America) journal has suggested that sight rather than sound plays a significantly more important role in deciding an expert’s opinion about a musical performance.

Sight over sound

The study, entitled ‘Sight over sound in the judgement of music performance’ by Chia-Jung Tsay of the Department of Management Science and Innovation at University College London, has just been published and has come up with some intriguing results.

It found that over 82% of professional musicians cited sound as the most important information required for making a judgement about a musical performance.

Only 25%

However, using the results of 10 actual music competition outcomes, only 25.7% of professional musicians subsequently identified the actual competition winner when using sound only in their decision making process.

Combining both audio and visual information the success rate rose to 29.5%, although using only silent visual information it soared to 47%.

Novice improvements

Meanwhile, 83% of novices also cited sound as the most important information required — with 28.8% identifying the actual winner when using sound only in their decision making process.

Combining both audio and visual information, the success rate rose to 35.4% — although using only silent visual information it soared to 46.4%.

Chance element

It is important to point out however that the element of chance of getting the same outcome as the actual result of the competitions used was calculated at 33% (experiment numbers ranged from 89 to 262 participants and all procedures were approved by the Harvard University Institutional Review Board).

No better?

So are novices better than professionals at judging a musical outcome, or are the professionals no better than getting it right than mere chance, even with sight and sound to help them?

And what explains the huge rise in successes rates when no sound is used – even though the actual outcomes were made by subjective opinion in the first place?

using the results of 10 actual music competition outcomes, only 25.7% of professional musicians subsequently identified the actual competition winner when using sound only in their decision making process4BR

At odds

It seems the outcome according to the report is fairly clear.

As it states: "It may be that regardless of training, knowledge and theories about the meaning of music, experts are just as vulnerable as novices to certain heuristics – ones that may be at odds with what is valued by the field."

The study also stated: "The dominance of visual information emerges to the degree that it is overweighted relative to auditory information, even when sound is consciously valued as the core domain content."

The report ends: "It is unsettling to find – and for musicians not to know – that they themselves relegate the sound of music to the role of noise."

To read the article in full go to:

http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2013/08/16/1221454110

Become a supporter and help make our future secure.

4barsrest continues to be a proudly independent voice. There are no paywalls to overcome to be able to enjoy what we do to keep our journalism at the heart of the brass banding world. Support us with a one-off donation or subscribe from just £2.50 per month.

Support us    


bopa

Brass Bands England challenge in Private Eye

November 19 • Support for BBE's challenge against losing its BOPA licencing role has come from a somewhat unexpected source.


Ivors

Nominations only at Ivor Composer Awards

November 19 • Composers with brass band links just miss out on this year's Ivor Composer Awards.


Hammonds Band

Yorkshire's Most Musical Job Interview

November 19 • A snippet gem from the BBC archives shows how they portrayed a job interview for an apprentice engineer at a well known sauce works that just happened to have a brass band...


radio

Radio: Touch of Brass

November 18 • More great brass band music to enjoy from presenters Martin Upfold and Julie Hedges.


Regent Hall Concerts - Band of the RAF Regiment Brass Ensemble

Friday 20 November • Regent Hall (The Salvation Army). 275 Oxford Street. London W1C2DJ


Bilton Silver Rugby Band - Bilton Silver President's Concert

Friday 27 November • St George's Church, St Johns Avenue, Rugby CV22 5HR


West Yorkshire Police Band - Mid Yorkshire Breast Cancer Support

Saturday 28 November • Cluntergate Centre, Horbury WF4 5DA


Newstead Brass - The Snowman - Live

Saturday 5 December • Forest Town Arena. Clipstone Road West, Forest Town. Mansfield NG19 0EE


Bilton Silver Rugby Band - Christmas Magic and More

Sunday 13 December • Rugby Theatre, Henry Street, Rugby, Warwickshire CV21 2QA


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Front Row Cornet player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a Eb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Crewe Brass

November 18 • Crewe Brass are looking for a BBb Bass player to join our highly motivated 4th section band. We are a very welcoming and sociable band, with a positive outlook and a reasonably busy calendar of engagements. Other enquiries are welcome.


Dave Collins

BA (Hons) (Dunelm) I, FSCO
Composer and Arranger


               

 © 2026 4barsrest.com Ltd